Heaven, in this world, where alone things change. (St. Jerome) --- Nothing is here perpetual, but to be used in a proper manner. (Worthington) --- The heart must not be attached to any thing created. (Calmet) --- Pleasure had been condemned and approved, chap. 2. He shews that all must have its time. (Menochius)
Friday of the 25th week in Ordinary Time
First Reading — Ecclesiastes 3:1-11
1All things have their season, and in their times all things pass under heaven.2A time to be born and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to destroy, and a time to build.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to get, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to keep silence, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What hath man more of his labour?10I have seen the trouble, which God hath given the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made all things good in their time, and hath delivered the world to their consideration, so that man cannot find out the work which God hath made from the beginning to the end.
1All things have their time, and all things under heaven continue during their interval.2A time to be born, and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pull up what was planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to tear down, and a time to build up.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to gain, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to be silent, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What more does a man have from his labor?10I have seen the affliction that God has given to the sons of men, in order that they may be occupied by it.11He has made all things good in their time, and he has handed over the world to their disputes, so that man may not discover the work which God made from the beginning, even until the end.
1To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:2A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;3A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;4A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;5A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;6A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;7A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;8A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace.9What profit hath he that worketh in that wherein he laboureth?10I have seen the travail, which God hath given to the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made every thing beautiful in his time: also he hath set the world in their heart, so that no man can find out the work that God maketh from the beginning to the end.
1All things have their season, and in their times all things pass under heaven.2A time to be born and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to destroy, and a time to build.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to get, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to keep silence, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What hath man more of his labour?10I have seen the trouble, which God hath given the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made all things good in their time, and hath delivered the world to their consideration, so that man cannot find out the work which God hath made from the beginning to the end.
1All things have their time, and all things under heaven continue during their interval.2A time to be born, and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pull up what was planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to tear down, and a time to build up.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to gain, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to be silent, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What more does a man have from his labor?10I have seen the affliction that God has given to the sons of men, in order that they may be occupied by it.11He has made all things good in their time, and he has handed over the world to their disputes, so that man may not discover the work which God made from the beginning, even until the end.
1To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:2A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;3A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;4A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;5A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;6A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;7A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;8A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace.9What profit hath he that worketh in that wherein he laboureth?10I have seen the travail, which God hath given to the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made every thing beautiful in his time: also he hath set the world in their heart, so that no man can find out the work that God maketh from the beginning to the end.
Responsorial Psalm — Psalm 144:1b and 2abc, 3-4
1Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight, and my fingers to war.2My mercy, and my refuge: my support, and my deliverer: My protector, and I have hoped in him: who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou art made known to him? or the son of man, that thou makest account of him?4Man is like to vanity: his days pass away like a shadow.
1A Psalm of David versus Goliath. Blessed is the Lord, my God, who trains my hands for the battle and my fingers for the war.2My mercy and my refuge, my supporter and my deliverer, my protector and him in whom I have hoped: he subdues my people under me.3O Lord, what is man that you have become known to him? Or the son of man that you consider him?4Man has been made similar to vanity. His days pass by like a shadow.
1Blessed be the Lord my strength, which teacheth my hands to war, and my fingers to fight:2My goodness, and my fortress; my high tower, and my deliverer; my shield, and he in whom I trust; who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou takest knowledge of him! or the son of man, that thou makest account of him!4Man is like to vanity: his days are as a shadow that passeth away.
1Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight, and my fingers to war.2My mercy, and my refuge: my support, and my deliverer: My protector, and I have hoped in him: who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou art made known to him? or the son of man, that thou makest account of him?4Man is like to vanity: his days pass away like a shadow.
1A Psalm of David versus Goliath. Blessed is the Lord, my God, who trains my hands for the battle and my fingers for the war.2My mercy and my refuge, my supporter and my deliverer, my protector and him in whom I have hoped: he subdues my people under me.3O Lord, what is man that you have become known to him? Or the son of man that you consider him?4Man has been made similar to vanity. His days pass by like a shadow.
1Blessed be the Lord my strength, which teacheth my hands to war, and my fingers to fight:2My goodness, and my fortress; my high tower, and my deliverer; my shield, and he in whom I trust; who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou takest knowledge of him! or the son of man, that thou makest account of him!4Man is like to vanity: his days are as a shadow that passeth away.
"Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight, and my fingers to war" (v. 1) — and the Hebrew behind "my God" is, Haydock notes, my rock. A man whose one famous victory was won by a stone blesses God under the name of stone. The fingers are not a poetic double of the hands: Haydock takes them for the fingers that chose the five pebbles out of the brook, and Berthier draws out the paradox that David had to exert himself entirely and then acknowledge that the whole success came from God, since, as Worthington observes, he had never been trained to war at all. The Douay title "against Goliath" is not in the Hebrew, which reads simply "of David." And when the psalm turns from victory to the victor in v. 4, the word for what man resembles is hebel — "nothing, a vapour," the same word that opens Ecclesiastes.
The added title divided the commentators. Hilary held that the Septuagint supplied it by inspiration, and Worthington that it fits because Goliath was David's first exploit in war; Calmet reports that others pay no deference to this part of the title, while noting that the Chaldean seems to allude to the same victory and the Syriac to David's defeat of Goliath's brother. The psalm was then read forward: Origen applied it to Zorobabel after the defeat of Gog, the Greek paraphrast to the Machabees, Kimchi and Goan to the Messias, the Fathers to Christ. Augustine makes the decisive move by pressing the detail rather than the date. David took five stones and hurled one — "the five Books were chosen, but unity conquered" — and then cut off Goliath's head with Goliath's own sword; so Christ overthrew the devil with the devil's own weapons, and the great men through whom he had killed souls now turn their tongues against him. On that reading the hands and the fingers of v. 1 are the Body of Christ, one work divided into many operations by the one Spirit, and the warfare is waged by works of mercy. Which is why the next word is "My mercy" (v. 2) — a title, Jerome says, that like all God's titles reminds us of his benefits, and one we can only use of him because we have received from him the mercy we show. Berthier keeps the victory honest: conquerors are generally in confusion, and only those who hold their own passions down are free.
"Lord, what is man, that thou art made known to him?" (v. 3). Augustine's gloss on the parallel verb is exact — valuing a thing means considering its price — and his example still lands: a man at a sale will pay more for a horse than for another man. Every modern instrument for pricing a life works the same way, by output, by the years remaining, by what the person costs to keep, and each returns the answer that some lives are cheap. God's valuation was the blood of his only Son, and Augustine's inference is that the same God will not now withhold anything smaller. What is asked in return is work, not sentiment: depart from evil, do good, seek peace. Berthier's image for what we are is the one to keep — a shadow that grows less distinct the longer it stretches; and Augustine's answer to it is to work with your hands while it is still night.
Gospel — Luke 9:18-22
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples also were with him: and he asked them, saying: Whom do the people say that I am?19But they answered and said: John the Baptist; but some say Elias: and others say that one of the former prophets is risen again.20And he said to them: But whom do you say that I am? Simon Peter answering, said: The Christ of God.21But he strictly charging them, commanded they should tell this to no man.22Saying: The Son of man must suffer many things and be rejected by the ancients and chief priests and scribes and be killed and the third day rise again.
18And it happened that, when he was praying alone, his disciples also were with him, and he questioned them, saying: “Who do the multitudes say that I am?”19But they answered by saying: “John the Baptist. But some say Elijah. Yet truly, others say that one of the prophets from before has risen again.”20Then he said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” In response, Simon Peter said, “The Christ of God.”21But speaking sharply to them, he instructed them not to tell this to anyone,22saying, “For the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and the leaders of the priests and the scribes, and be killed, and on the third day rise again.”
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am?19They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again.20He said unto them, But whom say ye that I am? Peter answering said, The Christ of God.21And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man that thing;22Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day.
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples also were with him: and he asked them, saying: Whom do the people say that I am?19But they answered and said: John the Baptist; but some say Elias: and others say that one of the former prophets is risen again.20And he said to them: But whom do you say that I am? Simon Peter answering, said: The Christ of God.21But he strictly charging them, commanded they should tell this to no man.22Saying: The Son of man must suffer many things and be rejected by the ancients and chief priests and scribes and be killed and the third day rise again.
18And it happened that, when he was praying alone, his disciples also were with him, and he questioned them, saying: “Who do the multitudes say that I am?”19But they answered by saying: “John the Baptist. But some say Elijah. Yet truly, others say that one of the prophets from before has risen again.”20Then he said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” In response, Simon Peter said, “The Christ of God.”21But speaking sharply to them, he instructed them not to tell this to anyone,22saying, “For the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and the leaders of the priests and the scribes, and be killed, and on the third day rise again.”
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am?19They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again.20He said unto them, But whom say ye that I am? Peter answering said, The Christ of God.21And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man that thing;22Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day.
Luke sets the question at prayer. Jesus is alone praying (v. 18), yet his disciples also were with him, and Witham resolves the apparent contradiction by taking "alone" to mean remote from the crowd. Augustine, in the Catena, faces a harder version of the problem, since Mark places the same question on the road. He answers that this "is difficult only to him who never prayed on the way." Peter's reply in v. 20 is shorter in Luke than in Matthew, The Christ of God, and Cyril of Alexandria says the Greek gives the title its article. Many were called christs in a lesser sense, anointed kings and prophets, and Christians themselves bear the name through the Spirit's anointing, but Peter names the one Christ who belongs to the Father. Cyril takes Luke's brief formula to agree in substance with Matthew's "Son of the living God."
The Fathers read the sequence of questions as teaching. Cyril says Christ's prayer might have perplexed men who had already watched him work miracles with divine power, and that he asked what the people said in order to clear away the crowd's opinion before drawing out their own. Theophylact adds that the order protected the disciples' confession from looking like a borrowed rumour, so that they would not be left "like Herod" among conflicting reports. Cyril dwells on the emphatic you of v. 20, which sets the witnesses of the miracles apart from the crowd, and on Peter's confession of one Christ against "those who presumed to divide Immanuel into two Christs," since the question was about the Son of man and the answer named the Son of God. The command to silence in v. 21 draws several explanations. Ambrose gives a list, among them to deceive the prince of this world, to refuse boasting, to teach humility, and to spare disciples still imperfect from an announcement too great for them. Chrysostom reasons like a gardener. A belief uprooted once and replanted rarely survives, and if Peter was offended merely by what he heard, those who heard "Son of God" and then saw him spat upon would fare worse. Cyril concludes that there is a time for everything, the cross and resurrection first and the preaching after.
The passage corrects an appetite for many opinions about Christ. Ambrose sets the crowd's list beside Paul's resolve to know nothing but Christ crucified and asks, "what more can I desire to know than Christ?" It equally corrects a confession made without the cross, because the first thing Christ says after Peter names him is that the Son of man must suffer many things (v. 22). Ambrose suggests he chose to announce his Passion himself because he knew they would believe even that. The scene keeps its first image, a man praying apart while his disciples wait near enough to be asked.
First Reading · Ecclesiastes 3:1-11
1All things have their season, and in their times all things pass under heaven.2A time to be born and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to destroy, and a time to build.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to get, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to keep silence, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What hath man more of his labour?10I have seen the trouble, which God hath given the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made all things good in their time, and hath delivered the world to their consideration, so that man cannot find out the work which God hath made from the beginning to the end.
1All things have their time, and all things under heaven continue during their interval.2A time to be born, and a time to die. A time to plant, and a time to pull up what was planted.3A time to kill, and a time to heal. A time to tear down, and a time to build up.4A time to weep, and a time to laugh. A time to mourn, and a time to dance.5A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather. A time to embrace, and a time to be far from embraces.6A time to gain, and a time to lose. A time to keep, and a time to cast away.7A time to rend, and a time to sew. A time to be silent, and a time to speak.8A time of love, and a time of hatred. A time of war, and a time of peace.9What more does a man have from his labor?10I have seen the affliction that God has given to the sons of men, in order that they may be occupied by it.11He has made all things good in their time, and he has handed over the world to their disputes, so that man may not discover the work which God made from the beginning, even until the end.
1To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:2A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;3A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;4A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;5A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;6A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;7A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;8A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace.9What profit hath he that worketh in that wherein he laboureth?10I have seen the travail, which God hath given to the sons of men to be exercised in it.11He hath made every thing beautiful in his time: also he hath set the world in their heart, so that no man can find out the work that God maketh from the beginning to the end.
Fourteen paired opposites run from v. 2 to v. 8, and the balance of the phrasing is so smooth that a reader slides past the strange ones. "A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather" (v. 5) sounds like housekeeping until Haydock's apparatus takes it to war: stones flung from a sling, or flung across a field to ruin it, as the good ground of Moab was spoiled in 4 Kings iii. 25, and as the vineyard of Isaias v. 2 had to be cleared before anything could be planted in it. The line that closes the catalogue is stranger still. Where the Douay has God "delivered the world to their consideration" (v. 11), the Latin word is disputationi — literally "dispute," a matter handed over to men to argue about rather than a subject offered for their reflection — while both the Hebrew and the Septuagint read simply "heart," and Pagnin renders the clause "He has implanted the desire of immortality in their hearts." Three readings, three accounts of what God put into man along with the seasons: an argument, an organ, or a hunger.
Jerome fixes the horizon of the whole list at the phrase "under heaven": this world, the only place where things change at all. Worthington takes the practical consequence — nothing here is perpetual, and what passes is therefore given to be used in a proper manner, not refused — while Calmet presses the same point to its sharp edge: the heart must not be attached to anything created. Menochius reads the chapter as the settling of an argument left open earlier, since pleasure had been both condemned and approved in chapter 2, and the contradiction dissolves once each thing is granted its hour. The hardest instance is the second half of v. 5, "a time to be far from embraces," which Jerome, Augustine in the Enchiridion, and Calmet all take of continence prescribed within marriage for a season (Leviticus xx. 18; 1 Corinthians vii) — the seasons run inside a lawful bond, not merely between good and evil. Haydock adds the bleaker observation that in v. 8 hatred is what often succeeds love. Everything then turns on how one hears the incapacity of v. 11. Calmet says that if we could discover the properties of each thing we should be in raptures; Menochius answers that precisely because we cannot, the failure only increases our vexation. The same withheld knowledge is either the promise of joy or the wound.
The passage rebukes, first, the conviction that timing is an engineering problem — that grief, work, and love can be sequenced correctly, and that a season one did not choose is a failure of management. Worthington's rule corrects it: the thing is to be used properly in its hour, not scheduled. It rebukes the opposite error just as hard, the conclusion that because nothing lasts one should hold what one has more tightly; Calmet's warning against attachment to anything created cuts exactly there. What the text positively requires is that the desire Pagnin found planted in the heart not be argued down to the size of what a life can finish. There is a season for gathering stones out of a field, and the man who spends his in that work will not see the vine.
Responsorial Psalm · Psalm 144:1b and 2abc, 3-4
1Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight, and my fingers to war.2My mercy, and my refuge: my support, and my deliverer: My protector, and I have hoped in him: who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou art made known to him? or the son of man, that thou makest account of him?4Man is like to vanity: his days pass away like a shadow.
1A Psalm of David versus Goliath. Blessed is the Lord, my God, who trains my hands for the battle and my fingers for the war.2My mercy and my refuge, my supporter and my deliverer, my protector and him in whom I have hoped: he subdues my people under me.3O Lord, what is man that you have become known to him? Or the son of man that you consider him?4Man has been made similar to vanity. His days pass by like a shadow.
1Blessed be the Lord my strength, which teacheth my hands to war, and my fingers to fight:2My goodness, and my fortress; my high tower, and my deliverer; my shield, and he in whom I trust; who subdueth my people under me.3Lord, what is man, that thou takest knowledge of him! or the son of man, that thou makest account of him!4Man is like to vanity: his days are as a shadow that passeth away.
"Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight, and my fingers to war" (v. 1) — and the Hebrew behind "my God" is, Haydock notes, my rock. A man whose one famous victory was won by a stone blesses God under the name of stone. The fingers are not a poetic double of the hands: Haydock takes them for the fingers that chose the five pebbles out of the brook, and Berthier draws out the paradox that David had to exert himself entirely and then acknowledge that the whole success came from God, since, as Worthington observes, he had never been trained to war at all. The Douay title "against Goliath" is not in the Hebrew, which reads simply "of David." And when the psalm turns from victory to the victor in v. 4, the word for what man resembles is hebel — "nothing, a vapour," the same word that opens Ecclesiastes.
The added title divided the commentators. Hilary held that the Septuagint supplied it by inspiration, and Worthington that it fits because Goliath was David's first exploit in war; Calmet reports that others pay no deference to this part of the title, while noting that the Chaldean seems to allude to the same victory and the Syriac to David's defeat of Goliath's brother. The psalm was then read forward: Origen applied it to Zorobabel after the defeat of Gog, the Greek paraphrast to the Machabees, Kimchi and Goan to the Messias, the Fathers to Christ. Augustine makes the decisive move by pressing the detail rather than the date. David took five stones and hurled one — "the five Books were chosen, but unity conquered" — and then cut off Goliath's head with Goliath's own sword; so Christ overthrew the devil with the devil's own weapons, and the great men through whom he had killed souls now turn their tongues against him. On that reading the hands and the fingers of v. 1 are the Body of Christ, one work divided into many operations by the one Spirit, and the warfare is waged by works of mercy. Which is why the next word is "My mercy" (v. 2) — a title, Jerome says, that like all God's titles reminds us of his benefits, and one we can only use of him because we have received from him the mercy we show. Berthier keeps the victory honest: conquerors are generally in confusion, and only those who hold their own passions down are free.
"Lord, what is man, that thou art made known to him?" (v. 3). Augustine's gloss on the parallel verb is exact — valuing a thing means considering its price — and his example still lands: a man at a sale will pay more for a horse than for another man. Every modern instrument for pricing a life works the same way, by output, by the years remaining, by what the person costs to keep, and each returns the answer that some lives are cheap. God's valuation was the blood of his only Son, and Augustine's inference is that the same God will not now withhold anything smaller. What is asked in return is work, not sentiment: depart from evil, do good, seek peace. Berthier's image for what we are is the one to keep — a shadow that grows less distinct the longer it stretches; and Augustine's answer to it is to work with your hands while it is still night.
Gospel · Luke 9:18-22
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples also were with him: and he asked them, saying: Whom do the people say that I am?19But they answered and said: John the Baptist; but some say Elias: and others say that one of the former prophets is risen again.20And he said to them: But whom do you say that I am? Simon Peter answering, said: The Christ of God.21But he strictly charging them, commanded they should tell this to no man.22Saying: The Son of man must suffer many things and be rejected by the ancients and chief priests and scribes and be killed and the third day rise again.
18And it happened that, when he was praying alone, his disciples also were with him, and he questioned them, saying: “Who do the multitudes say that I am?”19But they answered by saying: “John the Baptist. But some say Elijah. Yet truly, others say that one of the prophets from before has risen again.”20Then he said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” In response, Simon Peter said, “The Christ of God.”21But speaking sharply to them, he instructed them not to tell this to anyone,22saying, “For the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and the leaders of the priests and the scribes, and be killed, and on the third day rise again.”
18And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am?19They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again.20He said unto them, But whom say ye that I am? Peter answering said, The Christ of God.21And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man that thing;22Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day.
Luke sets the question at prayer. Jesus is alone praying (v. 18), yet his disciples also were with him, and Witham resolves the apparent contradiction by taking "alone" to mean remote from the crowd. Augustine, in the Catena, faces a harder version of the problem, since Mark places the same question on the road. He answers that this "is difficult only to him who never prayed on the way." Peter's reply in v. 20 is shorter in Luke than in Matthew, The Christ of God, and Cyril of Alexandria says the Greek gives the title its article. Many were called christs in a lesser sense, anointed kings and prophets, and Christians themselves bear the name through the Spirit's anointing, but Peter names the one Christ who belongs to the Father. Cyril takes Luke's brief formula to agree in substance with Matthew's "Son of the living God."
The Fathers read the sequence of questions as teaching. Cyril says Christ's prayer might have perplexed men who had already watched him work miracles with divine power, and that he asked what the people said in order to clear away the crowd's opinion before drawing out their own. Theophylact adds that the order protected the disciples' confession from looking like a borrowed rumour, so that they would not be left "like Herod" among conflicting reports. Cyril dwells on the emphatic you of v. 20, which sets the witnesses of the miracles apart from the crowd, and on Peter's confession of one Christ against "those who presumed to divide Immanuel into two Christs," since the question was about the Son of man and the answer named the Son of God. The command to silence in v. 21 draws several explanations. Ambrose gives a list, among them to deceive the prince of this world, to refuse boasting, to teach humility, and to spare disciples still imperfect from an announcement too great for them. Chrysostom reasons like a gardener. A belief uprooted once and replanted rarely survives, and if Peter was offended merely by what he heard, those who heard "Son of God" and then saw him spat upon would fare worse. Cyril concludes that there is a time for everything, the cross and resurrection first and the preaching after.
The passage corrects an appetite for many opinions about Christ. Ambrose sets the crowd's list beside Paul's resolve to know nothing but Christ crucified and asks, "what more can I desire to know than Christ?" It equally corrects a confession made without the cross, because the first thing Christ says after Peter names him is that the Son of man must suffer many things (v. 22). Ambrose suggests he chose to announce his Passion himself because he knew they would believe even that. The scene keeps its first image, a man praying apart while his disciples wait near enough to be asked.
· sources ·
The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.
First Reading Ecclesiastes 3:1-11
Stones, with a sling, or to render a field useless, 4 Kings iii. 25., and Isaias v. 2. --- Embraces. Continence was sometimes prescribed for married people, Leviticus xx. 18., and 1 Corinthians vii. (St. Jerome) (St. Augustine, Enchiridion 78.) (Calmet) --- Hatred often succeeds love, ver. 8., and 2 Kings xiii. 14. (Haydock)
Labour? What advantage does he derive from any of these things? (Chap. i. 3.) (Calmet)
Consideration. Literally, "dispute." Hebrew and Septuagint, "heart." (Haydock) --- Pagnin, "He has implanted the desire of immortality in their hearts." --- End. If we could discover the properties of each thing, we should be in raptures; (Calmet) but as we cannot, this increases our vexation. (Menochius)
1 To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven: 2 A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted; 3 A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up; 4 A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance; 5 A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing; 6 A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away; 7 A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak; 8 A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace. 9 What profit hath he that worketh in that wherein he laboureth? 10 I have seen the travail, which God hath given to the sons of men to be exercised in it.
The scope of these verses is to show, 1. That we live in a world of changes, that the several events of time, and conditions of human life, are vastly different from one another, and yet occur promiscuously, and we are continually passing and repassing between them, as in the revolutions of every day and every year. In the wheel of nature ( Jam. iii. 6 ) sometimes one spoke is uppermost and by and by the contrary; there is a constant ebbing and flowing, waxing and waning; from one extreme to the other does the fashion of this world change, ever did, and ever will. 2. That every change concerning us, with the time and season of it, is unalterably fixed and determined by a supreme power; and we must take things as they come, for it is not in our power to change what is appointed for us. And this comes in here as a reason why, when we are in prosperity, we should by easy, and yet not secure—not to be secure because we live in a world of changes and therefore have no reason to say, To-morrow shall be as this day (the lowest valleys join to the highest mountains), and yet to be easy, and, as he had advised ( ch. ii. 24 ), to enjoy the good of our labour, in a humble dependence upon God and his providence, neither lifted up with hopes, nor cast down with fears, but with evenness of mind expecting every event. Here we have,
I. A general proposition laid down: To every thing there is a season, v. 1 . 1. Those things which seem most contrary the one to the other will, in the revolution of affairs, each take their turn and come into play. The day will give place to the night and the night again to the day. Is it summer? It will be winter. Is it winter? Stay a while, and it will be summer. Every purpose has its time. The clearest sky will be clouded, Post gaudia luctus—Joy succeeds sorrow; and the most clouded sky will clear up, Post nubila Phoebus—The sun will burst from behind the cloud. 2. Those things which to us seem most casual and contingent are, in the counsel and foreknowledge of God, punctually determined, and the very hour of them is fixed, and can neither be anticipated nor adjourned a moment.
II. The proof and illustration of it by the induction of particulars, twenty-eight in number, according to the days of the moon's revolution, which is always increasing or decreasing between its full and change. Some of these changes are purely the act of God, others depend more upon the will of man, but all are determined by the divine counsel. Every thing under heaven is thus changeable, but in heaven there is an unchangeable state, and an unchangeable counsel concerning these things. 1. There is a time to be born and a time to die. These are determined by the divine counsel; and, as we were born, so we must die, at the time appointed, Acts xvii. 26 . Some observe that here is a time to be born and a time to die, but no time to live; that is so short that it is not worth mentioning; as soon as we are born we begin to die. But, as there is a time to be born and a time to die, so there will be a time to rise again, a set time when those that lie in the grave shall be remembered, Job xiv. 13 . 2. A time for God to plant a nation, as that of Israel in Canaan, and, in order to that, to pluck up the seven nations that were planted there, to make room for them; and at length there was a time when God spoke concerning Israel too, to pluck up and to destroy, when the measure of their iniquity was full, Jer. xviii. 7 , 9 . There is a time for men to plant, a time of the year, a time of their lives; but, when that which was planted has grown fruitless and useless, it is time to pluck it up. 3. A time to kill, when the judgments of God are abroad in a land and lay all waste; but, when he returns in ways of mercy, then is a time to heal what he has torn ( Hos. vi. 1, 2 ), to comfort a people after the time that he has afflicted them, Ps. xc. 15 . There is a time when it is the wisdom of rulers to use severe methods, but there is a time when it is as much their wisdom to take a more gentle course, and to apply themselves to lenitives, not corrosives. 4. A time to break down a family, an estate, a kingdom, when it has ripened itself for destruction; but God will find a time, if they return and repent, to rebuild what he has broken down; there is a time, a set time, for the Lord to build up Zion, Ps. cii. 13 , 16 . There is a time for men to break up house, and break off trade, and so to break down, which those that are busy in building up both must expect and prepare for. 5. A time when God's providence calls to weep and mourn, and when man's wisdom and grace will comply with the call, and will weep and mourn, as in times of common calamity and danger, and there it is very absurd to laugh, and dance, and make merry ( Isa. xxii. 12, 13 ; Ezek. xxi. 10 ); but then, on the other hand, there is a time when God calls to cheerfulness, a time to laugh and dance, and then he expects we should serve him with joyfulness and gladness of heart. Observe, The time of mourning and weeping is put first, before that of laughter and dancing, for we must first sow in tears and then reap in joy. 6. A time to cast away stones, by breaking down and demolishing fortifications, when God gives peace in the borders, and there is no more occasion for them; but there is a time to gather stones together, for the making of strong-holds, v. 5 . A time for old towers to fall, as that in Siloam ( Luke xii. 4 ), and for the temple itself to be so ruined as that not one stone should be left upon another; but also a time for towers and trophies too to be erected, when national affairs prosper. 7. A time to embrace a friend when we find him faithful, but a time to refrain from embracing when we find he is unfair or unfaithful, and that we have cause to suspect him; it is then our prudence to be shy and keep at a distance. It is commonly applied to conjugal embraces, and explained by 1 Cor. vii. 3-5 ; Joel ii. 16 . 8. A time to get, get money, get preferment, get good bargains and a good interest, when opportunity smiles, a time when a wise man will seek (so the word is); when he is setting out in the world and has a growing family, when he is in his prime, when he prospers and has a run of business, then it is time for him to be busy and make hay when the sun shines. There is a time to get wisdom, and knowledge, and grace, when a man has a price put into his hand; but then let him expect there will come a time to spend, when all he has will be little enough to serve his turn. Nay, there will come a time to lose, when what has been soon got will be soon scattered and cannot be held fast. 9. A time to keep, when we have use for what we have got, and can keep it without running the hazard of a good conscience; but there may come a time to cast away, when love to God may oblige us to cast away what we have, because we must deny Christ and wrong our consciences if we keep it ( Matt. x. 37, 38 ), and rather to make shipwreck of all than of the faith; nay, when love to ourselves may oblige us to cast it away, when it is for the saving of our lives, as it was when Jonah's mariners heaved their cargo into the sea. 10. A time to rend the garments, as upon occasion of some great grief, and a time to sew, them again, in token that the grief is over. A time to undo what we have done and a time to do again what we have undone. Jerome applies this to the rending of the Jewish church and the sewing and making up of the gospel church thereupon. 11. A time when it becomes us, and is our wisdom and duty, to keep silence, when it is an evil time ( Amos v. 13 ), when our speaking would be the casting of pearl before swine, or when we are in danger of speaking amiss ( Ps. xxxix. 2 ); but there is also a time to speak for the glory of God and the edification of others, when silence would be the betraying of a righteous cause, and when with the mouth confession is to be made to salvation; and it is a great part of Christian prudence to know when to speak and when to hold our peace. 12. A time to love, and to show ourselves friendly, to be free and cheerful, and it is a pleasant time; but there may come a time to hate, when we shall see cause to break off all familiarity with some that we have been fond of, and to be upon the reserve, as having found reason for a suspicion, which love is loth to admit. 13. A time of war, when God draws the sword for judgment and gives it commission to devour, when men draw the sword for justice and the maintaining of their rights, when there is in the nations a disposition to war; but we may hope for a time of peace, when the sword of the Lord shall be sheathed and he shall make wars to cease ( Ps. xlvi. 9 ), when the end of the war is obtained, and when there is on all sides a disposition to peace. War shall not last always, nor is there any peace to be called lasting on this side the everlasting peace. Thus in all these changes God has set the one over-against the other, that we may rejoice as though we rejoiced not and weep as though we wept not.
11 He hath made every thing beautiful in his time: also he hath set the world in their heart, so that no man can find out the work that God maketh from the beginning to the end. 12 I know that there is no good in them, but for a man to rejoice, and to do good in his life. 13 And also that every man should eat and drink, and enjoy the good of all his labour, it is the gift of God. 14 I know that, whatsoever God doeth, it shall be for ever: nothing can be put to it, nor any thing taken from it: and God doeth it, that men should fear before him. 15 That which hath been is now; and that which is to be hath already been; and God requireth that which is past.
We have seen what changes there are in the world, and must not expect to find the world more sure to us than it has been to others. Now here Solomon shows the hand of God in all those changes; it is he that has made every creature to be that to us which it is, and therefore we must have our eye always upon him.
I. We must make the best of that which is, and must believe it best for the present, and accommodate ourselves to it: He has made every thing beautiful in his time ( v. 11 ), and therefore, while its time lasts, we must be reconciled to it: nay, we must please ourselves with the beauty of it. Note, 1. Every thing is as God has made it; it is really as he appointed it to be, not as it appears to us. 2. That which to us seems most unpleasant is yet, in its proper time, altogether becoming. Cold is as becoming in winter as heat in summer; and the night, in its turn, is a black beauty, as the day, in its turn, is a bright one. 3. There is a wonderful harmony in the divine Providence and all its disposals, so that the events of it, when they come to be considered in their relations and tendencies, together with the seasons of them, will appear very beautiful, to the glory of God and the comfort of those that trust in him. Though we see not the complete beauty of Providence, yet we shall see it, and a glorious sight it will be, when the mystery of God shall be finished. Then every thing shall appear to have been done in the most proper time and it will be the wonder of eternity, Deut. xxxii. 4 ; Ezek. i. 18 .
II. We must wait with patience for the full discovery of that which to us seems intricate and perplexed, acknowledging that we cannot find out the work that God makes from the beginning to the end, and therefore must judge nothing before the time. We are to believe that God has made all beautiful. Every thing is done well, as in creation, so in providence, and we shall see it when the end comes, but till then we are incompetent judges of it. While the picture is in drawing, and the house in building, we see not the beauty of either; but when the artist has put his last hand to them, and given them their finishing strokes, then all appears very good. We see but the middle of God's works, not from the beginning of them (then we should see how admirably the plan was laid in the divine counsels), nor to the end of them, which crowns the action (then we should see the product to be glorious), but we must wait till the veil be rent, and not arraign God's proceedings nor pretend to pass judgment on them. Secret things belong not to us. Those words, He has set the world in their hearts, are differently understood. 1. Some make them to be a reason why we may know more of God's works than we do; so Mr. Pemble: "God has not left himself without witness of his righteous, equal, and beautiful ordering of things, but has set it forth, to be observed in the book of the world, and this he has set in men's hearts, given man a large desire, and a power, in good measure, to comprehend and understand the history of nature, with the course of human affairs, so that, if men did but give themselves to the exact observation of things, they might in most of them perceive an admirable order and contrivance." 2. Others make them to be a reason why we do not know so much of God's works as we might; so bishop Reynolds: "We have the world so much in our hearts, are so taken up with thoughts and cares of worldly things, and are so exercised in our travail concerning them, that we have neither time nor spirit to eye God's hand in them." The world has not only gained possession of the heart, but has formed prejudices there against the beauty of God's works.
III. We must be pleased with our lot in this world, and cheerfully acquiesce in the will of God concerning us, and accommodate ourselves to it. There is no certain, lasting, good in these things; what good there is in them we are here told, v. 12, 13 . We must make a good use of them, 1. For the benefit of others. All the good there is in them is to do good with them, to our families, to our neighbours, to the poor, to the public, to its civil and religious interests. What have we our beings, capacities, and estates for, but to be some way serviceable to our generation? We mistake if we think we were born for ourselves. No; it is our business to do good; it is in doing good that there is the truest pleasure, and what is so laid out is best laid up and will turn to the best account. Observe, It is to do good in this life, which is short and uncertain; we have but a little time to be doing good in, and therefore had need to redeem time. It is in this life, where we are in a state of trial and probation for another life. Every man's life is his opportunity of doing that which will make for him in eternity. 2. For our own comfort. Let us make ourselves easy, rejoice, and enjoy the good of our labour, as it is the gift of God, and so enjoy God in it, and taste his love, return him thanks, and make him the centre of our joy, eat and drink to his glory, and serve him with joyfulness of heart, in the abundance of all things. If all things in this world be so uncertain, it is a foolish thing for men sordidly to spare for the present, that they may hoard up all for hereafter; it is better to live cheerfully and usefully upon what we have, and let to-morrow take thought for the things of itself. Grace and wisdom to do this is the gift of God, and it is a good gift, which crowns the gifts of his providential bounty.
IV. We must be entirely satisfied in all the disposals of the divine Providence, both as to personal and public concerns, and bring our minds to them, because God, in all, performs the thing that is appointed for us, acts according to the counsel of his will; and we are here told, 1. That that counsel cannot be altered, and therefore it is our wisdom to make a virtue of necessity, by submitting to it. It must be as God wills: I know (and every one knows it that knows any thing of God) that whatsoever God does it shall be for ever, v. 14 . He is in one mind, and who can turn him? His measures are never broken, nor is he ever put upon new counsels, but what he has purposed shall be effected, and all the world cannot defeat nor disannul it. It behoves us therefore to say, "Let it be as God wills," for, how cross soever it may be to our designs and interests, God's will is his wisdom. 2. That that counsel needs not to be altered, for there is nothing amiss in it, nothing that can be amended. If we could see it altogether at one view, we should see it so perfect that nothing can be put to it, for there is no deficiency in it, nor any thing taken from it, for there is nothing in it unnecessary, or that can be spared. As the word of God, so the works of God are every one of them perfect in its kind, and it is presumption for us either to add to them or to diminish from them, Deut. iv. 2 . It is therefore as much our interest, as our duty, to bring our wills to the will of God.
V. We must study to answer God's end in all his providences, which is in general to make us religious. God does all that men should fear before him, to convince them that there is a God above them that has a sovereign dominion over them, at whose disposal they are and all their ways, and in whose hands their times are and all events concerning them, and that therefore they ought to have their eyes ever towards him, to worship and adore him, to acknowledge him in all their ways, to be careful in every thing to please him, and afraid of offending him in any thing. God thus changes his disposals, and yet is unchangeable in his counsels, not to perplex us, much less to drive us to despair, but to teach us our duty to him and engage us to do it. That which God designs in the government of the world is the support and advancement of religion among men.
Ec 3:1-22 .
Earthly pursuits are no doubt lawful in their proper time and order ( Ec 3:1-8 ), but unprofitable when out of time and place; as for instance, when pursued as the solid and chief good ( Ec 3:9 , 10 ); whereas God makes everything beautiful in its season, which man obscurely comprehends ( Ec 3:11 ). God allows man to enjoy moderately and virtuously His earthly gifts ( Ec 3:12 , 13 ). What consoles us amidst the instability of earthly blessings is, God's counsels are immutable ( Ec 3:14 ).
1. Man has his appointed cycle of seasons and vicissitudes, as the sun, wind, and water ( Ec 1:5-7 ).
purpose-- as there is a fixed "season" in God's "purposes" (for example, He has fixed the "time" when man is "to be born," and "to die," Ec 3:2 ), so there is a lawful "time" for man to carry out his "purposes" and inclinations. God does not condemn, but approves of, the use of earthly blessings ( Ec 3:12 ); it is the abuse that He condemns, the making them the chief end ( 1Co 7:31 ). The earth, without human desires, love, taste, joy, sorrow, would be a dreary waste, without water; but, on the other hand, the misplacing and excess of them, as of a flood, need control. Reason and revelation are given to control them.
2. time to die-- ( Psa 31:15 ; He 9:27 ).
plant-- A man can no more reverse the times and order of "planting," and of "digging up," and transplanting, than he can alter the times fixed for his "birth" and "death." To try to "plant" out of season is vanity, however good in season; so to make earthly things the chief end is vanity, however good they be in order and season. Gill takes it, not so well, figuratively ( Jr 18:7 , 9 ; Am 9:15 ; Mt 15:13 ).
3. time to kill-- namely, judicially, criminals; or, in wars of self-defense; not in malice. Out of this time and order, killing is murder.
to heal-- God has His times for "healing" (literally, Is 38:5 , 21 ; figuratively, De 32:39 ; Ho 6:1 ; spiritually, Psa 147:3 ; Is 57:19 ). To heal spiritually, before the sinner feels his wound, would be "out of time," and so injurious.
time to break down-- cities, as Jerusalem, by Nebuchadnezzar.
build up-- as Jerusalem, in the time of Zerubbabel; spiritually ( Am 9:11 ), "the set time" ( Psa 102:13-16 ).
4. mourn-- namely, for the dead ( Ge 23:2 ).
dance-- as David before the ark ( 2Sa 6:12-14 ; Psa 30:11 ); spiritually ( Mt 9:15 ; Lu 6:21 ; 15:25 ). The Pharisees, by requiring sadness out of time, erred seriously.
5. cast away stones-- as out of a garden or vineyard ( Is 5:2 ).
gather-- for building; figuratively, the Gentiles, once castaway stones, were in due time made parts of the spiritual building ( Ep 2:19 , 20), and children of Abraham ( Mt 3:9 ); so the restored Jews hereafter ( Psa 102:13 , 14 ; Zec 9:16 ).
refrain ... embracing-- ( Joe 2:16 ; 1Co 7:5 , 6 ).
6. time to get-- for example, to gain honestly a livelihood ( Ep 4:23 ).
lose-- When God wills losses to us, then is our time to be content.
keep-- not to give to the idle beggar ( 2Th 3:10 ).
cast away-- in charity ( Pr 11:24 ); or to part with the dearest object, rather than the soul ( Mr 9:43 ). To be careful is right in its place, but not when it comes between us and Jesus Christ ( Lu 10:40-42 ).
7. rend-- garments, in mourning ( Joe 2:13 ); figuratively, nations, as Israel from Judah, already foretold, in Solomon's time ( 1Ki 11:30 , 31 ), to be "sewed" together hereafter ( Eze 37:15 , 22 ).
silence-- ( Am 5:13 ), in a national calamity, or that of a friend ( Job 2:13 ); also not to murmur under God's visitation ( Le 10:3 ; Psa 39:1 , 2, 9).
8. hate-- for example, sin, lusts ( Lu 14:26 ); that is, to love God so much more as to seem in comparison to hate "father or mother," when coming between us and God.
a time of war ... peace-- ( Lu 14:31 ).
9. But these earthly pursuits, while lawful in their season, are "unprofitable" when made by man, what God never intended them to be, the chief good. Solomon had tried to create an artificial forced joy, at times when he ought rather to have been serious; the result, therefore, of his labor to be happy, out of God's order, was disappointment. "A time to plant" ( Ec 3:2 ) refers to his planting ( Ec 2:5 ); "laugh" ( Ec 3:4 ), to Ec 2:1 , 2 ; "his mirth," "laughter"; "build up," "gather stones" ( Ec 3:3 , 5 ), to his "building" ( Ec 2:4 ); "embrace," "love," to his "princess" (see on Ec 2:8 ); "get" (perhaps also "gather," Ec 3:5 , 6 ), to his "gathering" ( Ec 2:8 ). All these were of "no profit," because not in God's time and order of bestowing happiness.
10. (See on Ec 1:13 ).
11. his time-- that is, in its proper season ( Psa 1:3 ), opposed to worldlings putting earthly pursuits out of their proper time and place (see on Ec 3:9 ).
set the world in their heart-- given them capacities to understand the world of nature as reflecting God's wisdom in its beautiful order and times ( Ro 1:19 , 20 ). "Everything" answers to "world," in the parallelism.
so that-- that is, but in such a manner that man only sees a portion, not the whole "from beginning to end" ( Ec 8:17 ; Job 26:14 ; Ro 11:33 ; Re 15:4 ). Parkhurst, for "world," translates: "Yet He hath put obscurity in the midst of them," literally, "a secret," so man's mental dimness of sight as to the full mystery of God's works. So Holden and Weiss. This incapacity for "finding out" (comprehending) God's work is chiefly the fruit of the fall. The worldling ever since, not knowing God's time and order, labors in vain, because out of time and place.
Responsorial Psalm Psalm 144:1b and 2abc, 3-4
1. The title of this Psalm is brief in number of words, but heavy in the weight of its mysteries. "To David himself against Goliath." This battle was fought in the time of our fathers, and ye, beloved, remember it with me from Holy Scripture....David put five stones in his scrip, he hurled but one. The five Books were chosen, but unity conquered. Then, having smitten and overthrown him, he took the enemy's sword, and with it cut off his head. This our David also did, He overthrew the devil with his own weapons: and when his great ones, whom he had in his power, by means of whom he slew other souls, believe, they turn their tongues against the devil, and so Goliath's head is cut off with his own sword.
2. "Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands for battle, my fingers for war"
(ver. 1). These are our words, if we be the Body of Christ. It seems a repetition of sentiment; "our hands for battle," and "our fingers for war," are the same. Or is there some difference between "hands" and "fingers"? Certainly both hands and fingers work. Not then without reason do we take "fingers" as put for "hands." But still in the "fingers" we recognise the division of operation, yet still a sort of unity. Behold that grace! the Apostle saith, To one, this; to another, that; "there are diversities of operations; all these worketh one and the self-same Spirit;" there is the root of unity. With these "fingers" then the Body of Christ fighteth, going forth to "war," going forth to "battle."...By works of Mercy our enemy is conquered, and we could not have works of mercy unless we had charity, and charity we could have none unless we received it by the Holy Ghost; He then "teacheth our hands for battle, and our fingers for war:" to Him rightfully do we say, "My Mercy," from whom we have also that we are merciful: "for he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath showed no mercy."
3. My Mercy and my Refuge, my Upholder and my Deliverer"
(ver. 2). Much toileth this combatant, having his flesh lusting against his spirit. Keep what thou hast. Then shalt thou have in full what thou wishest, when "death shall have been swallowed up in victory;" when this mortal body has been raised, and is changed into the condition of the angels, and rises aloft to a heavenly quality....There is life, there are good days, where nought lusteth against the spirit, where it is not said, "Fight," but "Rejoice." But who is he that lusteth for these days? Every man certainly saith, "I do." Hear what followeth. I see that thou art toiling, I see that thou art engaged in battle, and in danger; hear what followeth:..."Depart from evil, and do good:" let not the poor first weep under thee, that the poor may rejoice through thee. For what reward, since now thou art fighting? "Seek peace, and ensue it." Learn and say, "My Mercy and my Refuge, mine Upholder and my Deliverer, my Protector:" "mine Upholder," lest I fall; "my Deliverer," lest I stick; "my Protector," lest I be stricken. In all these things, in all my toil, in all my battles, in all my difficulties, in Him have I hoped, "who subdueth my people under me." Behold, our Head speaketh together with us.
4. "Lord, what is man, that Thou hast become known unto him?"
(ver. 3). All is included in "that Thou hast become known unto him." "Or the son of man, that Thou valuest him?" Thou valuest him, that is, Thou makest him of such importance, Thou countest him of such price, Thou knowest under what Thou placest him, over what Thou placest him. For valuing is considering the price of a thing. How greatly did He value man, who for him shed the blood of His only-begotten Son! For God valueth not man in the same way as one man valueth another: he, when he findeth a slave for sale, giveth a higher price for a horse than for a man. Consider how greatly He valued thee, that thou mayest be able to say, "If God be for us, who can be against us?" And how greatly did He value thee, "who spared not His own Son"? "How shall He not also with Him freely give us all things?" He who giveth this food to the combatant, what keepeth He in store for the conqueror?...
5. "Man is made like unto vanity: his days pass away like a shadow"
(ver. 4). What vanity? Time, which passeth on, and floweth by. For this "vanity" is said in comparison of the Truth, which ever abideth, and never faileth: for it too is a work of His Hand, in its degree. "For," as it is written, "God filled the earth with His good things." What is "His"? That accord with Him. But all these things, being earthly, fleeting, transitory, if they be compared to that Truth, where it is said, "I Am That I Am," all this which passeth away is called "vanity." For through time it vanisheth, like stroke into the air. And why should I say more than that which the Apostle James said, willing to bring down proud men to humility, "What is," saith he, "your life? It is even a vapour, which appeareth for a little time, and then vanisheth away." ...Work then, though it be in the night, with thine hands, that is, by good works seek God, before the day come which shall gladden thee, lest the day come which shall sadden thee. For see how safely thou workest, who art not left by Him whom thou seekest; "that thy Father which seeth in secret may reward thee openly." ...
6. "Lord, bow Thy heavens, and come down: touch the mountains, and they shall smoke"
Goliath. Hebrew has simply, "of David." (Haydock) --- St. Hilary thinks that the Septuagint added the rest by inspiration, (Calmet) because this was David's first exploit in war. (Worthington) --- But others pay no deference to this part of the title. The Chaldean, however, seems to allude to the same victory, (ver. 10.) and the Syriac to that which David obtained over Asaph, brother of Goliath, 1 Paralipomenon xx. 5. (Calmet) --- David prays that he may overcome the Philistines, and give thanks in Psalm xvii. (Ferrand) --- These two psalms are very much alike, and this seems to have been written after the rebels were discomfited, while the 17th expresses the sentiments of the prophet, towards the end of his life, for all his victories. (Calmet) --- Zorobabel after the defeat of Gog, (Ezechiel xxxviii.; Origen) or the Machabees; (Greek paraphrast.) or Jesus Christ might adopt these sentiments. (Holy Fathers) --- Kimchi and Goan refer the psalm to the Messias. (Calmet) --- God. Hebrew, "rock." --- Fingers. Which chose the five pebbles. He was to exert himself, and yet to acknowledge that all success came from God. (Berthier) --- He had not been trained to war, when he overcame Goliath. (Worthington)
Mercy. "All the titles of God remind us of his benefits." (St. Jerome) --- My people. After the defeat of the rebels, (Calmet) and the death of Isboseth. (Berthier) --- Hebrew may also be "peoples," as Psalm xvii, (Syriac, &c.) including them, and the various nations that were subdued by David. (Calmet) --- Conquerors are generally in confusion, while those who keep their passions under are free, 2 Corinthians iii. 17. (Berthier)
To him. Hebrew, "thou dost acknowledge him." (St. Jerome) (Haydock) --- In the transport of gratitude, he reflects on his own weakness, Job vii. 17., and Romans viii. 31. (Calmet) --- Before Christ, all mankind were undeserving of revelation. (Worthington)
Vanity. Hebrew hebel, "nothing, a vapour," &c., Ecclesiastes i. 1., and James iv. 15. (Haydock) --- Our lives resemble a shadow, which is the less distinct, the more it increases. (Berthier) --- As it cannot subsist of itself, so neither can man without God. (Worthington)
1 Blessed be the Lord my strength, which teacheth my hands to war, and my fingers to fight: 2 My goodness, and my fortress; my high tower, and my deliverer; my shield, and he in whom I trust; who subdueth my people under me. 3 Lord , what is man, that thou takest knowledge of him! or the son of man, that thou makest account of him! 4 Man is like to vanity: his days are as a shadow that passeth away. 5 Bow thy heavens, O Lord , and come down: touch the mountains, and they shall smoke. 6 Cast forth lightning, and scatter them: shoot out thine arrows, and destroy them. 7 Send thine hand from above; rid me, and deliver me out of great waters, from the hand of strange children; 8 Whose mouth speaketh vanity, and their right hand is a right hand of falsehood.
Here, I. David acknowledges his dependence upon God and his obligations to him, v. 1, 2 . A prayer for further mercy is fitly begun with a thanksgiving for former mercy; and when we are waiting upon God to bless us we should stir up ourselves to bless him. He gives to God the glory of two things:—
1. What he was to him: Blessed be the Lord my rock ( v. 1 ), my goodness, my fortress, v. 2 . He has in the covenant engaged himself to be so, and encouraged us, accordingly, to depend upon him; all the saints, who by faith have made him theirs, have found him not only to answer but to out do their expectations. David speaks of it here as the matter of his trust, and that which made him easy, as the matter of his triumph, and that which made him glad, and in which he gloried. See how he multiplies words to express the satisfaction he had in God and his interest in him. (1.) "He is my strength, on whom I stay, and from whom I have power both for my work and for my warfare, my rock to build on, to take shelter in." Even when we are weak we may be strong in the Lord and in the power of his might. (2.) " My goodness, not only good to me, but my chief good, in whose favour I place my felicity, and who is the author of all the goodness that is in me, and from whom comes every good and perfect gift. " (3.) " My fortress, and my high tower, in whom I think myself as safe as ever any prince thought himself in a castle or strong-hold." David had formerly sheltered himself in strong-holds at En-gedi ( 1 Sam. xxiii. 29 ), which perhaps were natural fastnesses. He had lately made himself master of the strong-hold of Zion, which was fortified by art, and he dwelt in the fort ( 2 Sam. v. 7 , 9 ), but he depends not on these. "Lord," says he, "thou art my fortress and my high tower. " The divine attributes and promises are fortifications to a believer, far exceeding those either of nature or art. (4.) My deliverer, and, as it is in the original, very emphatically, my deliverer to me, "not only a deliverer I have interest in, but who is always nigh unto me and makes all my deliverances turn to my real benefit." (5.) " My shield, to guard me against all the malignant darts that my enemies let fly at me, not only my fortress at home, but my shield abroad in the field of battle." Wherever a believer goes he carries his protection along with him. Fear not, Abram, I am thy shield.
2. What he had done for him. He was bred a shepherd, and seems not to have been designed by his parents, or himself for any thing more. But, (1.) God had made him a soldier. His hands had been used to the crook and his fingers to the harp, but God taught his hands to war and his fingers to fight, because he designed him for Israel's champion; and what God calls men to he either finds them or makes them fit for. Let the men of war give God the glory of all their military skill; the same that teaches the meanest husbandman his art teaches the greatest general his. It is a pity that any whose fingers God has taught to fight should fight against him or his kingdom among men. Those have special reason to acknowledge God with thankfulness who prove to be qualified for services which they themselves never thought of. (2.) God had made him a sovereign prince, had taught him to wield the sceptre as well as the sword, to rule as well as fight, the harder and nobler art of the two: He subdueth my people under me. The providence of God is to be acknowledged in making people subject to their prince, and so preserving the order and benefit of societies. There was a special hand of God inclining the people of Israel to be subject to David, pursuant to the promise God had made him; and it was typical of that great act of divine grace, the bringing of souls into subjection to the Lord Jesus and making them willing in the day of his power.
II. He admires God's condescension to man and to himself in particular ( v. 3, 4 ): " Lord, what is man, what a poor little thing is he, that thou takest knowledge of him, that thou makest account of him, that he falls so much under thy cognizance and care, and that thou hast such a tender regard to any of that mean and worthless race as thou hast had to me!" Considering the many disgraces which the human nature lies under, we have reason to admire the honours God has put upon mankind in general (the saints especially, some in a particular manner, as David) and upon the Messiah (to whom those words are applied, Heb. ii. 6 ), who was highly exalted because he humbled himself to be found in fashion as a man, and has authority to execute judgment because he is the Son of man. A question to this purport David asked ( Ps. viii. 4 ), and he illustrated the wonder by the consideration of the great dignity God has placed man in ( Ps. viii. 5 ), Thou hast crowned him with glory and honour. Here he illustrates it by the consideration of the meanness and mortality of man, notwithstanding the dignity put upon him ( v. 4 ): Man is like to vanity; so frail is he, so weak, so helpless, compassed about with so many infirmities, and his continuance here so very short and uncertain, that he is as like as may be to vanity itself. Nay, he is vanity, he is so at his best estate. His days have little substance in them, considering how many of the thoughts and cares of an immortal soul are employed about a poor dying body; they are as a shadow, dark and flitting, transitory and finishing with the sun, and, when that sets, resolving itself into all shadow. They are as a shadow that passeth away, and there is no loss of it. David puts himself into the number of those that are thus mean and despicable.
Gospel Luke 9:18-22
CHAPTER 9
Ver. 14.Make them sit down by fifties in a company, κλισίας, i.e. in companies, in ranks or rows. Syriac.
And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am?19. They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again.20. He said to them, But whom say you that I am? Peter answering said, The Christ of God.21. And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man that thing;22. Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and Chief Priests and Scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day.
Our Lord having retired from the multitude, and being in a place apart, was engaged in prayer. As it is said, And it came to pass, as he was alone praying. For He ordained Himself as an example of this, instructing His disciples by an easy’ method of teaching. For I suppose the rulers of the people ought to be superior also in good deeds, to those that are under them, ever holding converse with them in all necessary things, and treating of those things in which God delights.
Now the disciples were with the Lord, but He alone prayed to the Father, since the saints may be joined to the Lord in the bond of faith and love, but the Son alone is able to penetrate the incomprehensible secrets of the Father’s will. Every where then He prays alone, for human wishes comprehend not the counsel of God, nor can any one be a partaker with Christ of the deep things of God.
Now His engaging in prayer might perplex His disciples. For they saw Him praying like a man, Whom before they had seen performing miracles with divine power. In order then to banish all perplexity of this kind, He asks them this question, not because He did not know the reports which they had gathered from without, but that He might rid them of the opinion of the many, and instill into them the true faith. Hence it follows, And he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am?
Rightly does our Lord, when about to inquire into the faith of the disciples, first inquire into the opinion of the multitudes, lest their confession should appear not to be determined by their knowledge, but to be formed by the opinion of the generality, and they should be considered not to believe from experience, but like Herod to be perplexed by different reports which they heard.
Now it may raise a question, that Luke says that our Lord asked His disciples, Whom do men say that I am? at the same time that He was alone praying, and they also were with Him; whereas Mark says, that they were asked this question by our Lord on the way; but this is difficult only to him who never prayed on the way.
But it is no trifling opinion of the multitude which the disciples mention, when it is added, But they answering said, John the Baptist, (whom they knew to be beheaded;) but some say, Elias, (whom they thought would come,) but others say that one of the old Prophets is risen again. But to make this inquiry belongs to a different kind of wisdom from ours, for if it were enough for the Apostle Paul to know nothing but Christ Jesus, and Him crucified, what more can I desire to know than Christ?
But mark the subtle skill of the question. For he directs them first to the praises of strangers, that having overthrown these, He might beget in them the right opinion. So when the disciples had given the opinion of the people, He asks them their own opinion; as it is added, And He said to them, Whom say you that I am? How marked is you! He excludes them from the other, that they may avoid their opinions; as if He said, you who by my decree are called to the Apostleship, the witnesses of my miracles, whom do you say that I am? But Peter anticipated the rest, and becomes the mouthpiece of the whole company, and launching forth into the eloquence of divine love, utters the confession of faith, as it is added, Peter answering said, The Christ of God. He says not merely that He was Christ of God, but now He uses the article. Hence it is in the Greek. For many divinely accounted persons are in diverse ways called Christs, for some were anointed kings, some prophets. But we through Christ have been anointed by the holy Spirit, have obtained the name of Christ. But there is only one who is the Christ of God and the Father, He alone as it were having His own Father who is in heaven. And so Luke agrees indeed in the same opinion as Matthew, who relates Peter to have said, You are Christ, the Son of the living God, but speaking briefly Luke says that Peter answered, the Christ of God.
In this one name there is the expression both of His divinity and incarnation, and the belief of His passion. He has therefore comprehended every thing, having expressed both the nature and tile name wherein is all virtue.
But we must observe, that Peter most wisely confessed Christ to be one, against those who presumed to divide Immanuel into two Christs. For Christ did not inquire of them, saying, Whom do men say the divine Word is? but the Son of man, whom Peter confessed to be the Son of God. Herein then is Peter to be admired, and thought worthy of such chief honor, seeing that Him whom he marveled at in our form, he believed to be the Christ of the Father, that is to say, that the Word which proceeded of the Father’s Substance was become man.
But our Lord Jesus Christ was as at first unwilling to be preached, lest an uproar should arise; as it follows, And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man any thing. For many reasons He commands His disciples to be silent; to deceive the prince of this world, to reject boasting, to teach humility. Christ then would not boast, and cost you boast who are of ignoble birth? Likewise He did it to prevent rude and as yet imperfect disciples from being oppressed with the wonder of this awful announcement. They are then forbid to preach Him as the Son of God, that they might afterwards preach Him crucified.
Timely also was our Lord’s command that no one should tell that He was Christ, in order that when offenses should be taken away and the sufferings of the cross completed, a proper opinion of Him might be firmly rooted in the minds of the hearers. For that which has once taken root and afterwards been torn up, when fresh planted will scarcely ever be preserved. But that which when once planted continues undisturbed, grows up securely. For if Peter was offended merely by what he heard, what would be the feelings of those many who, after they had heard that He was the Son of God, saw Him crucified, and spit upon?
It was the duty then of the disciples to preach Him throughout the world. For this was the work of those who were chosen by Him to the office of the Apostleship. But as holy Scripture bears witness, There is a time for every thing. For it was fitting that the cross and resurrection should be accomplished, an d then should follow the preaching of the Apostles; as it is spoken, saying, The Son of man must needs suffer many things.
Perhaps because the Lord knew that the disciples would believe even the difficult mystery of the Passion and Resurrection, He wished to be Himself the proclaimer of His own Passion and Resurrection.
As he was alone praying: i.e. remote from the people, though his disciples are said to have been with him. (Witham)
18 And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am? 19 They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again. 20 He said unto them, But whom say ye that I am? Peter answering said, The Christ of God. 21 And he straitly charged them, and commanded them to tell no man that thing; 22 Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day. 23 And he said to them all, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow me. 24 For whosoever will save his life shall lose it: but whosoever will lose his life for my sake, the same shall save it. 25 For what is a man advantaged, if he gain the whole world, and lose himself, or be cast away? 26 For whosoever shall be ashamed of me and of my words, of him shall the Son of man be ashamed, when he shall come in his own glory, and in his Father's, and of the holy angels. 27 But I tell you of a truth, there be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the kingdom of God.
In these verses, we have Christ discoursing with his disciples about the great things that pertained to the kingdom of God; and one circumstance of this discourse is taken notice of here which we had not in the other evangelists-that Christ was alone praying, and his disciples with him, when he entered into this discourse, v. 18 . Observe, 1. Though Christ had much public work to do, yet he found some time to be alone in private, for converse with himself, with his Father, and with his disciples. 2. When Christ was alone he was praying. It is good for us to improve our solitude for devotion, that, when we are alone, we may not be alone, but may have the Father with us. 3. When Christ was alone, praying, his disciples were with him, to join with him in his prayer; so that this was a family-prayer. Housekeepers ought to pray with their households, parents with their children, masters with their servants, teachers and tutors with their scholars and pupils. 4. Christ prayed with them before he examined them, that they might be directed and encouraged to answer him, by his prayers for them. Those we give instructions to we should put up prayers for and with. He discourses with them,
I. Concerning himself; and enquires,
1. What the people said of him: Who say the people that I am? Christ knew better than they did, but would have his disciples made sensible, by the mistakes of others concerning him, how happy they were that were led into the knowledge of him and of the truth concerning him. We should take notice of the ignorance and errors of others, that we may be the more thankful to him who has manifested himself to us, and not unto the world, and may pity them, and do what we can to help them and to teach them better. They tell him what conjectures concerning him they had heard in their converse with the common people. Ministers would know better how to suit their instructions, reproofs, and counsels, to the case of ordinary people, if they did but converse more frequently and familiarly with them; they would then be the better able to say what is proper to rectify their notions, correct their irregularities, and remove their prejudices. The more conversant the physician is with his patient, the better he knows what to do for him. Some said that he was John Baptist, who was beheaded but the other day; others Elias, or one of the old prophets; any thing but what he was.
2. What they said of him. "Now see what an advantage you have by your discipleship; you know better." "So we do," saith Peter, "thanks be to our Master for it; we know that thou art the Christ of God, the Anointed of God, the Messiah promised." It is matter of unspeakable comfort to us that our Lord Jesus is God's anointed, for then he has unquestionable authority and ability for his undertaking; for his being anointed signifies his being both appointed to it and qualified for it. Now one would have expected that Christ should have charged his disciples, who were so fully apprized and assured of this truth, to publish it to every one they met with; but no, he strictly charged them to tell no man that thing as yet, because there is a time for all things. After his resurrection, which completed the proof of it, Peter made the temple ring of it, that God had made this same Jesus both Lord and Christ ( Acts ii. 36 ); but as yet the evidence was not ready to be summed up, and therefore it must be concealed; while it was so, we may conclude that the belief of it was not necessary to salvation.
II. Concerning his own sufferings and death, of which he had yet said little. Now that his disciples were well established in the belief of his being the Christ, and able to bear it, he speaks of them expressly, and with great assurance, v. 22 . It comes in as a reason why they must not yet preach that he was the Christ, because the wonders that would attend his death and resurrection would be the most convincing proof of his being the Christ of God. It was by his exaltation to the right hand of the Father that he was fully declared to be the Christ, and by the sending of the Spirit thereupon ( Acts ii. 33 ); and therefore wait till that is done.
III. Concerning their sufferings for him. So far must they be from thinking how to prevent his sufferings that they must rather prepare for their own.
1. We must accustom ourselves to all instances of self-denial and patience, v. 23 . This is the best preparative for martyrdom. We must live a life of self-denial, mortification, and contempt of the world; we must not indulge our ease and appetite, for then it will be hard to bear toil, and weariness, and want, for Christ. We are daily subject to affliction, and we must accommodate ourselves to it, and acquiesce in the will of God in it, and must learn to endure hardship. We frequently meet with crosses in the way of duty; and, though we must not pull them upon our own heads, yet, when they are laid for us, we must take them up, carry them after Christ, and make the best of them.
2. We must prefer the salvation and happiness of our souls before any secular concern whatsoever. Reckon upon it, (1.) That he who to preserve his liberty or estate, his power or preferment, nay, or to save his life, denies Christ and his truths, wilfully wrongs his conscience, and sins against God, will be, not only not a saver, but an unspeakable loser, in the issue, when profit and loss come to be balanced: He that will save his life upon these terms will lose it, will lose that which is of infinitely more value, his precious soul. (2.) We must firmly believe also that, if we lose our life for cleaving to Christ and our religion, we shall save it to our unspeakable advantage; for we shall be abundantly recompensed in the resurrection of the just, when we shall have it again a new and an eternal life. (3.) That the gain of all the world, if we should forsake Christ, and fall in with the interests of the world, would be so far from countervailing the eternal loss and ruin of the soul that it would bear no manner of proportion to it, v. 25 . If we could be supposed to gain all the wealth, honour, and pleasure, in the world, by denying Christ, yet when, by so doing, we lose ourselves to all eternity, and are cast away at last, what good will our worldly gain do us? Observe, In Matthew and Mark the dreadful issue is a man's losing his own soul, here it is losing himself, which plainly intimates that our souls are ourselves. Animus cujusque is est quisque—The soul is the man; and it is well or ill with us according as it is well or ill with our souls. If they perish for ever, under the weight of their own guilt and corruption, it is certain that we are undone. The body cannot be happy if the soul be miserable in the other world; but the soul may be happy though the body be greatly afflicted and oppressed in this world. If a man be himself cast away, e zemiotheis — if he be damaged, —or if he be punished, si mulctetur—if he have a mulct put upon his soul by the righteous sentence of Christ, whose cause and interest he has treacherously deserted,—if it be adjudged a forfeiture of all his blessedness, and the forfeiture be taken, where is his gain? What is his hope?
3. We must therefore never be ashamed of Christ and his gospel, nor of any disgrace or reproach that we may undergo for our faithful adherence to him and it, v. 26 . For whosoever shall be ashamed of me and of my words, of him shall the Son of man be ashamed, and justly. When the service and honour of Christ called for his testimony and agency, he denied them, because the interest of Christ was a despised interest, and every where spoken against; and therefore he can expect no other than that in the great day, when his case calls for Christ's appearance on his behalf, Christ will be ashamed to own such a cowardly, worldly, sneaking spirit, and will say, "He is none of mine; he belongs not to me." As Christ had a state of humiliation and of exaltation, so likewise has his cause. They, and they only, that are willing to suffer with it when it suffers, shall reign with it when it reigns; but those that cannot find in their hearts to share with it in its disgrace, and to say, If this be to be vile, I will be yet more vile, shall certainly have no share with it in its triumphs. Observe here, How Christ, to support himself and his followers under present disgraces, speaks magnificently of the lustre of his second coming, in prospect of which he endured the cross, despising the shame. (1.) He shall come in his own glory. This was not mentioned in Matthew and Mark. He shall come in the glory of the Mediator, all the glory which the Father restored to him, which he had with God before the worlds were, which he had deposited and put in pledge, as it were, for the accomplishing of his undertaking, and demanded again when he had gone through it. Now, O Father, glorify thou me, John xvii. 4, 5 . He shall come in all that glory which the Father conferred upon him when he set him at his own right hand, and gave him to be head over all things to the church; in all the glory that is due to him as the assertor of the glory of God, and the author of the glory of all the saints. This is his own glory. (2.) He shall come in his Father's glory. The Father will judge the world by him, having committed all judgment to him; and therefore will publicly own him in the judgment as the brightness of his glory and the express image of his person. (3.) He shall come in the glory of the holy angels. They shall all attend him, and minister to him, and add every thing they can to the lustre of his appearance. What a figure will the blessed Jesus make in that day! Did we believe it, we should never be ashamed of him or his words now.
Fourteen paired opposites run from v. 2 to v. 8, and the balance of the phrasing is so smooth that a reader slides past the strange ones. "A time to scatter stones, and a time to gather" (v. 5) sounds like housekeeping until Haydock's apparatus takes it to war: stones flung from a sling, or flung across a field to ruin it, as the good ground of Moab was spoiled in 4 Kings iii. 25, and as the vineyard of Isaias v. 2 had to be cleared before anything could be planted in it. The line that closes the catalogue is stranger still. Where the Douay has God "delivered the world to their consideration" (v. 11), the Latin word is disputationi — literally "dispute," a matter handed over to men to argue about rather than a subject offered for their reflection — while both the Hebrew and the Septuagint read simply "heart," and Pagnin renders the clause "He has implanted the desire of immortality in their hearts." Three readings, three accounts of what God put into man along with the seasons: an argument, an organ, or a hunger.
Jerome fixes the horizon of the whole list at the phrase "under heaven": this world, the only place where things change at all. Worthington takes the practical consequence — nothing here is perpetual, and what passes is therefore given to be used in a proper manner, not refused — while Calmet presses the same point to its sharp edge: the heart must not be attached to anything created. Menochius reads the chapter as the settling of an argument left open earlier, since pleasure had been both condemned and approved in chapter 2, and the contradiction dissolves once each thing is granted its hour. The hardest instance is the second half of v. 5, "a time to be far from embraces," which Jerome, Augustine in the Enchiridion, and Calmet all take of continence prescribed within marriage for a season (Leviticus xx. 18; 1 Corinthians vii) — the seasons run inside a lawful bond, not merely between good and evil. Haydock adds the bleaker observation that in v. 8 hatred is what often succeeds love. Everything then turns on how one hears the incapacity of v. 11. Calmet says that if we could discover the properties of each thing we should be in raptures; Menochius answers that precisely because we cannot, the failure only increases our vexation. The same withheld knowledge is either the promise of joy or the wound.
The passage rebukes, first, the conviction that timing is an engineering problem — that grief, work, and love can be sequenced correctly, and that a season one did not choose is a failure of management. Worthington's rule corrects it: the thing is to be used properly in its hour, not scheduled. It rebukes the opposite error just as hard, the conclusion that because nothing lasts one should hold what one has more tightly; Calmet's warning against attachment to anything created cuts exactly there. What the text positively requires is that the desire Pagnin found planted in the heart not be argued down to the size of what a life can finish. There is a season for gathering stones out of a field, and the man who spends his in that work will not see the vine.