✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 452 · Year II · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year II

Thursday of the 25th week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · Ecclesiastes 1:2-11

2Vanity of vanities, said Ecclesiastes: vanity of vanities, and all is vanity.3What hath a man more of all his labour, that he taketh under the sun?4One generation passeth away, and another generation cometh: but the earth standeth for ever.5The sun riseth, and goeth down, and returneth to his place: and there rising again,6Maketh his round by the south, and turneth again to the north: the spirit goeth forward surveying all places round about, and returneth to his circuits.7All the rivers run into the sea, yet the sea doth not overflow: unto the place from whence the rivers come, they return, to flow again.8All things are hard: man cannot explain them by word. The eye is not filled with seeing, neither is the ear filled with hearing.9What is it that hath been? the same thing that shall be. What is it that hath been done? the same that shall be done.10Nothing under the sun is new, neither is any man able to say: Behold this is new: for it hath already gone before in the ages that were before us.11There is no remembrance of former things: nor indeed of those things which hereafter are to come, shall there be any remembrance with them that shall be in the latter end.

commentary

Augustine once built a doctrine on a copyist's slip in this verse. His text read vanitantium — the vanity "of those made vain" — and from it he inferred that the futility of things under the sun is an effect of man's sin; later he found he had read incorrectly, and said so in the Retractations (i. 7). The word is in fact the ordinary Hebrew superlative, and the commentators take it as such: Calmet reads "vanity of vanities" as the most vain and despicable, Menochius as what frustrates the expectations of men. The correction matters more than it looks. Augustine's misreading had made the emptiness a sentence passed on the world; the text as it stands leaves it a description of how the world runs — generations passing while the earth stands (v. 4), the sun going down and returning to its place, and all the rivers running into a sea that does not fill (v. 7). Nothing is being punished in those verses. Something is being measured.

The commentators then argue about how literally to take the machinery. Jerome reads the "spirit" of v. 6 as the sun, which is like the soul of the world — and Haydock immediately guards the phrase, since some have falsely asserted the sun to be animated; Calmet and Menochius, citing Pliny, take the word for the wind instead, one rising in different quarters of the world as another falls. At v. 7 Haydock notes that Homer describes the rivers and the sea in the same terms, and that the sea returns what it takes in the form of vapour. "The earth standeth for ever" gets a similar two-step: Calmet holds that its substance remains though the form be changed, Worthington that at the end of time it will be purified to continue for ever. Then at v. 10 Calmet draws the line the book itself leaves undrawn — "nothing new under the sun" must not be stretched into the eternity of the world, nor into a series of worlds preceding this one, as Origen would suppose. Worthington, citing Aquinas, supplies the principle that keeps the verse honest: souls are created daily and are nevertheless of the same sort as Adam's, and creatures proceed from others of the same species which have been from the beginning. Sameness of kind is not the eternity of the world. Menochius reduces the whole claim to its modest form — natural and moral things continue much the same.

Haydock lets Seneca press the point of v. 3 from outside the canon: men fight for a mere point, since that is what the earth amounts to compared with the universe, and the note sets Matthew 16:26 beside it. The error the passage rebukes is no longer Origen's cosmology but its inversion — the assumption that whatever recurs can be discounted, that repetition is itself the proof of meaninglessness, which is exactly how the labour, the generations and the rivers get read now. Haydock closes that exit at v. 8, where all things are hard and man cannot explain them by word: in every science there are many difficulties, and if a man had arrived at perfect knowledge his researches would cease. The unfilled eye is not a defect in the eye; it is the condition of continuing to look. What the passage asks is not resignation but a correction to what one expects the labour under the sun to yield. The rivers do run to the sea, and the sea does not overflow, and they go back to the place they came from — to flow again.

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading Ecclesiastes 1:2-11

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
1:2

Vanities. Most vain and despicable, (Calmet) and frustrating the expectations of men. (Menochius) --- St. Augustine reads vanitantium, and infers that this vanity of sublunary things is an effect of man's sin. Yet he afterwards discovered that he had read incorrectly. (Retractions i. 7.)

1:3

Labour. People fight for a mere point; for such is the earth compared with the universe. (Seneca, q. Nat.) Hoc est punctum, &c., Matthew xvi. 26.

1:4

Ever. Its substance remains, though the form be changed. (Calmet) --- At the end of time, it will be purified to continue for ever. (Worthington)

1:5

Place daily. Its annual motion is then mentioned. (Calmet)

1:6

Spirit. The sun, (St. Jerome) which is like the soul of the world, and which some have falsely asserted to be animated; or rather (Calmet) the wind is meant, as one rises in different parts of the world when another falls. (Pliny, [Natural History?] ii. 27.) (Menochius)

1:7

Again. The sea furnishes vapours, &c. Homer (Iliad Greek: Ph.) expresses himself in the same manner.

1:8

Hearing. In all sciences there are many difficulties. If a man had arrived at perfect knowledge, his researches would cease.

1:10

New. Such vicissitudes have occurred before, though we must not infer that the world is eternal; or that there have been many others before this, as Origen would suppose. (Prin. iii. 5., &c.) (Calmet) --- Men's souls, which are created daily, are nevertheless of the same sort as Adam's was; and creatures proceed from others of the same species, which have been from the beginning. (St. Thomas Aquinas, [Summa Theologiae] p. 1. q. 73.) (Worthington) --- Natural and moral things continue much the same. (Menochius)

1:11

Things. Otherwise we should read of similar events to those which we behold. The same cause naturally produces the same effect.