Offerings. He cannot otherwise observe the law. (Haydock) --- Virtue is the most acceptable sacrifice. (Calmet) --- The sacrifices of penance, of justice, and of praise, are to be preferred before all external ones. (Worthington)
Tuesday of the 8th week in Ordinary Time
First Reading — Sirach 35:1-12
1He that keepeth the law, multiplieth offerings.2It is a wholesome sacrifice to take heed to the commandments, and to depart from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice, is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices, and a begging of pardon for sins.4He shall return thanks, that offereth fine flour: and he that doth mercy, offereth sacrifice.5To depart from iniquity is that which pleaseth the Lord, and to depart from injustice, is an entreaty for sins.6Thou shalt not appear empty in the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just maketh the altar fat, and is an odour of sweetness in the sight of the most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will not forget the memorial thereof.10Give glory to God with a good heart: and diminish not the firstfruits of thy hands.11In every gift shew a cheerful countenance, and sanctify thy tithes with joy.12Give to the most High according to what he hath given to thee, and with a good eye do according to the ability of thy hands:
1Whoever observes the law multiplies oblations.2It is a salutary sacrifice to attend to the commandments and to withdraw from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices and a supplication for sins.4Whoever gives thanks, offers a gift of fine flour, and whoever acts with mercy, offers a sacrifice.5To withdraw from iniquity is well-pleasing to the Lord. And to withdraw from injustice is a supplication for sins.6You should not appear empty before the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just fattens the altar, and is a fragrance of sweetness in the sight of the Most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will never forget the memorial of it.10Render glory to God with a good heart. And you should not reduce the first-fruits of your hands.11With every gift, have a cheerful countenance, and sanctify your tithes with exultation.12Give to the Most High according to his gifts to you, and act with a good eye toward the creations of your hands.
1He that keepeth the law bringeth offerings enough: he that taketh heed to the commandment offereth a peace offering.2He that requiteth a good turn offereth fine flour; and he that giveth alms sacrificeth praise.3To depart from wickedness is a thing pleasing to the Lord; and to forsake unrighteousness is a propitiation.4Thou shalt not appear empty before the Lord.5For all these things are to be done because of the commandment.6The offering of the righteous maketh the altar fat, and the sweet savour thereof is before the most High.7The sacrifice of a just man is acceptable. and the memorial thereof shall never be forgotten.8Give the Lord his honour with a good eye, and diminish not the firstfruits of thine hands.9In all thy gifts shew a cheerful countenance, and dedicate thy tithes with gladness.10Give unto the most High according as he hath enriched thee; and as thou hast gotten, give with a cheerful eye.11For the Lord recompenseth, and will give thee seven times as much.12Do not think to corrupt with gifts; for such he will not receive: and trust not to unrighteous sacrifices; for the Lord is judge, and with him is no respect of persons.
1He that keepeth the law, multiplieth offerings.2It is a wholesome sacrifice to take heed to the commandments, and to depart from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice, is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices, and a begging of pardon for sins.4He shall return thanks, that offereth fine flour: and he that doth mercy, offereth sacrifice.5To depart from iniquity is that which pleaseth the Lord, and to depart from injustice, is an entreaty for sins.6Thou shalt not appear empty in the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just maketh the altar fat, and is an odour of sweetness in the sight of the most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will not forget the memorial thereof.10Give glory to God with a good heart: and diminish not the firstfruits of thy hands.11In every gift shew a cheerful countenance, and sanctify thy tithes with joy.12Give to the most High according to what he hath given to thee, and with a good eye do according to the ability of thy hands:
1Whoever observes the law multiplies oblations.2It is a salutary sacrifice to attend to the commandments and to withdraw from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices and a supplication for sins.4Whoever gives thanks, offers a gift of fine flour, and whoever acts with mercy, offers a sacrifice.5To withdraw from iniquity is well-pleasing to the Lord. And to withdraw from injustice is a supplication for sins.6You should not appear empty before the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just fattens the altar, and is a fragrance of sweetness in the sight of the Most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will never forget the memorial of it.10Render glory to God with a good heart. And you should not reduce the first-fruits of your hands.11With every gift, have a cheerful countenance, and sanctify your tithes with exultation.12Give to the Most High according to his gifts to you, and act with a good eye toward the creations of your hands.
1He that keepeth the law bringeth offerings enough: he that taketh heed to the commandment offereth a peace offering.2He that requiteth a good turn offereth fine flour; and he that giveth alms sacrificeth praise.3To depart from wickedness is a thing pleasing to the Lord; and to forsake unrighteousness is a propitiation.4Thou shalt not appear empty before the Lord.5For all these things are to be done because of the commandment.6The offering of the righteous maketh the altar fat, and the sweet savour thereof is before the most High.7The sacrifice of a just man is acceptable. and the memorial thereof shall never be forgotten.8Give the Lord his honour with a good eye, and diminish not the firstfruits of thine hands.9In all thy gifts shew a cheerful countenance, and dedicate thy tithes with gladness.10Give unto the most High according as he hath enriched thee; and as thou hast gotten, give with a cheerful eye.11For the Lord recompenseth, and will give thee seven times as much.12Do not think to corrupt with gifts; for such he will not receive: and trust not to unrighteous sacrifices; for the Lord is judge, and with him is no respect of persons.
Responsorial Psalm — Psalm 50:5-6, 7-8, 14, 23
5Gather ye together his saints to him: who set his covenant before sacrifices.6And the heavens shall declare his justice: for God is judge.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak: O Israel, and I will testify to thee: I am God, thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices: and thy burnt offerings are always in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise: and pay thy vows to the most High.23The sacrifice of praise shall glorify me: and there is the way by which I will shew him the salvation of God.
5Gather his holy ones to him, you who order his covenant above sacrifices.6And the heavens will announce his justice. For God is the judge.7Listen, my people, and I will speak. Listen, Israel, and I will testify for you. I am God, your God.8I will not reprove you for your sacrifices. Moreover, your holocausts are ever in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise, and pay your vows to the Most High.23The sacrifice of praise will honor me. And in that place is the journey by which I will reveal to him the salvation of God.
5Gather my saints together unto me; those that have made a covenant with me by sacrifice.6And the heavens shall declare his righteousness: for God is judge himself. Selah.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak; O Israel, and I will testify against thee: I am God, even thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices or thy burnt offerings, to have been continually before me.14Offer unto God thanksgiving; and pay thy vows unto the most High:23Whoso offereth praise glorifieth me: and to him that ordereth his conversation aright will I shew the salvation of God.
5Gather ye together his saints to him: who set his covenant before sacrifices.6And the heavens shall declare his justice: for God is judge.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak: O Israel, and I will testify to thee: I am God, thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices: and thy burnt offerings are always in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise: and pay thy vows to the most High.23The sacrifice of praise shall glorify me: and there is the way by which I will shew him the salvation of God.
5Gather his holy ones to him, you who order his covenant above sacrifices.6And the heavens will announce his justice. For God is the judge.7Listen, my people, and I will speak. Listen, Israel, and I will testify for you. I am God, your God.8I will not reprove you for your sacrifices. Moreover, your holocausts are ever in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise, and pay your vows to the Most High.23The sacrifice of praise will honor me. And in that place is the journey by which I will reveal to him the salvation of God.
5Gather my saints together unto me; those that have made a covenant with me by sacrifice.6And the heavens shall declare his righteousness: for God is judge himself. Selah.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak; O Israel, and I will testify against thee: I am God, even thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices or thy burnt offerings, to have been continually before me.14Offer unto God thanksgiving; and pay thy vows unto the most High:23Whoso offereth praise glorifieth me: and to him that ordereth his conversation aright will I shew the salvation of God.
The psalm stages a trial. God summons His people, the heavens testify, and the charge turns out not to concern sacrifices at all: I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices (v. 8). Verse 5 is obscure. The Hebrew calls the gathered "my merciful ones," and the Douay's who set his covenant before sacrifices can also be rendered, as Haydock notes, "who make a covenant with him respecting sacrifices," the Protestant reading being "by sacrifice"; Menochius observes that sacrifice generally preceded a covenant. The resolution comes in the command of verse 14, Offer to God the sacrifice of praise, repeated as the psalm's last word (v. 23). Augustine stops on the word holocaust, which he explains as holon, "whole," and causis, "burning": a whole consumed with fire.
On who the gathered saints are, Calmet says the chosen people, Theodoret the priests, whom Chrysostom thinks may have valued the legal sacrifices too highly, and Eusebius all the elect. Augustine reads the gathering as the last judgment and the saints as those "that have had compassion on the needy," setting God's promises above their own works; the heavens that declare his justice (v. 6) are, for Jerome and Augustine, the Apostles and Evangelists. The commentators agree that the psalm does not abolish sacrifice by decree. Worthington and Calmet say outward sacrifices pleased God but were of no service to Him, since the whole world is His already, and that praise and a contrite heart must accompany them if they are to be acceptable. Augustine's holocaust settles the question from the inside. The holocaust always in God's sight is a mind "inflamed with love," which will not let the limbs serve cupidity, and the abandoned calves and he-goats foretold "a certain Sacrifice which was to be, with the Blood whereof we should be cleansed." Worthington, citing Augustine, sees the psalm proving that the old victims must give place to the body of Christ, and Haydock adds that Eucharist means thanksgiving, the tribute of praise God requires.
Augustine meets a poor man's fear that God will demand what he lacks: God "doth not exact what He hath not given." No one needs to go into Arabia for frankincense, because the altar is one's conscience; Zacchaeus had the sacrifice of praise in his patrimony, the widow in her bag, another man "wholly in his heart." He denies the name of praise to two counterfeits. One is the man who lives ill and speaks well. The other is the man who lives well and credits his merits, and so the publican went down justified rather than the Pharisee. Verse 23 promises the salvation of God, which Augustine identifies with Christ, shown to the sinner who copies the publican and, in his words, will "show wounds, beseech Physician."
Gospel — Mark 10:28-31
28And Peter began to say unto him: Behold, we have left all things and have followed thee.29Jesus answering said: Amen I say to you, there is no man who hath left house or brethren or sisters or father or mother or children or lands, for my sake and for the gospel,30Who shall not receive an hundred times as much, now in this time: houses and brethren and sisters and mothers and children and lands, with persecutions: and in the world to come life everlasting.31But many that are first shall be last: and the last, first.
28And Peter began to say to him, “Behold, we have left all things and have followed you.”29In response, Jesus said: “Amen I say to you, There is no one who has left behind house, or brothers, or sisters, or father, or mother, or children, or land, for my sake and for the Gospel,30who will not receive one hundred times as much, now in this time: houses, and brothers, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and land, with persecutions, and in the future age eternal life.31But many of the first shall be last, and the last shall be first.”
28Then Peter began to say unto him, Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee.29And Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my sake, and the gospel’s,30But he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions; and in the world to come eternal life.31But many that are first shall be last; and the last first.
28And Peter began to say unto him: Behold, we have left all things and have followed thee.29Jesus answering said: Amen I say to you, there is no man who hath left house or brethren or sisters or father or mother or children or lands, for my sake and for the gospel,30Who shall not receive an hundred times as much, now in this time: houses and brethren and sisters and mothers and children and lands, with persecutions: and in the world to come life everlasting.31But many that are first shall be last: and the last, first.
28And Peter began to say to him, “Behold, we have left all things and have followed you.”29In response, Jesus said: “Amen I say to you, There is no one who has left behind house, or brothers, or sisters, or father, or mother, or children, or land, for my sake and for the Gospel,30who will not receive one hundred times as much, now in this time: houses, and brothers, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and land, with persecutions, and in the future age eternal life.31But many of the first shall be last, and the last shall be first.”
28Then Peter began to say unto him, Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee.29And Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my sake, and the gospel’s,30But he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions; and in the world to come eternal life.31But many that are first shall be last; and the last first.
Peter's Behold, we have left all things (v. 28) is an odd boast, and Theophylact says so: Peter had left but few things, and still calls these his all — because even a few things keep us by the bond of affection, so that he shall be beatified who leaves a few. The Gloss supplies the pressure behind the question: the rich young man had just gone away sorrowful, and the disciples, who had already done what he could not bear to hear, began to ask about their reward, thinking it a great thing. Bede notices what Peter is careful to add. It is not sufficient to have left all, so he adds what makes up perfection, and have followed thee — "as if he said, We have done what Thou hast commanded. What reward therefore wilt Thou give us?" The answer does not stay where the question was put: Peter asks only about the disciples, Theophylact observes, and the Lord replies generally, of any man who has left house or brethren for the gospel.
What the hundredfold amounts to has been fought over. Bede attacks those who read it of a thousand years after the resurrection of the just, when all that was given up is restored with interest — "that Jewish fable" — and argues textually, not merely indignantly: the other Evangelists list a hundred wives, which makes the promise's foulness plain; the Lord testifies that there is no marriage in the resurrection; and he says the restoration comes now in this time, with persecutions, which on the millenarians' own account their thousand years will not contain. The catena's own editorial note records that some early Fathers, Augustine and Irenaeus among them, did hold a doctrine of the Millennium; Bede's target is narrower than his phrasing suggests. Pseudo-Chrysostom states the alternative flatly: the reward is in participation, not possession, fulfilled spiritually and not carnally. Theophylact cashes it out in specifics: many women busied themselves about the Apostles' food and clothing, and Peter, having left one house, afterwards had the houses of all the disciples. On with persecutions Lapide offers two readings without choosing. Jerome and Bede take it that a hundred — that is, very many — will succour the persecuted man as brothers, fathers and mothers, which is marvellous because persecution is when a man is normally left destitute, everyone withdrawing for fear. Or the persecutions may themselves belong to the reward, since to suffer for Christ is a great gift of God.
The saying is easily turned into a licence, and Theophylact blocks that first: it does not mean leaving one's parents without helping them, or separating from one's wife, but preferring the glory of God to the things of this world. Chrysostom hears in the same verse a covert warning of what was coming — that many fathers would allure their sons to impiety and many wives their husbands — which is still the ordinary shape of the cost: pressure at close range, from people with a real claim on one's affection. Bede aims many that are first shall be last at the professionally religious. He daily sees men in a lay habit eminent for their meritorious life, while others ardent from youth in a spiritual profession wither away in the sloth of ease and "with a lazy folly finish in the flesh, what they had begun in the Spirit." His image for the reward is not a warning but a hand. A hundred is counted by moving from the left hand to the right; the fingers bend into the same shape they made for ten, and the quantity is enormously greater.
First Reading · Sirach 35:1-12
1He that keepeth the law, multiplieth offerings.2It is a wholesome sacrifice to take heed to the commandments, and to depart from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice, is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices, and a begging of pardon for sins.4He shall return thanks, that offereth fine flour: and he that doth mercy, offereth sacrifice.5To depart from iniquity is that which pleaseth the Lord, and to depart from injustice, is an entreaty for sins.6Thou shalt not appear empty in the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just maketh the altar fat, and is an odour of sweetness in the sight of the most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will not forget the memorial thereof.10Give glory to God with a good heart: and diminish not the firstfruits of thy hands.11In every gift shew a cheerful countenance, and sanctify thy tithes with joy.12Give to the most High according to what he hath given to thee, and with a good eye do according to the ability of thy hands:
1Whoever observes the law multiplies oblations.2It is a salutary sacrifice to attend to the commandments and to withdraw from all iniquity.3And to depart from injustice is to offer a propitiatory sacrifice for injustices and a supplication for sins.4Whoever gives thanks, offers a gift of fine flour, and whoever acts with mercy, offers a sacrifice.5To withdraw from iniquity is well-pleasing to the Lord. And to withdraw from injustice is a supplication for sins.6You should not appear empty before the sight of the Lord.7For all these things are to be done because of the commandment of God.8The oblation of the just fattens the altar, and is a fragrance of sweetness in the sight of the Most High.9The sacrifice of the just is acceptable, and the Lord will never forget the memorial of it.10Render glory to God with a good heart. And you should not reduce the first-fruits of your hands.11With every gift, have a cheerful countenance, and sanctify your tithes with exultation.12Give to the Most High according to his gifts to you, and act with a good eye toward the creations of your hands.
1He that keepeth the law bringeth offerings enough: he that taketh heed to the commandment offereth a peace offering.2He that requiteth a good turn offereth fine flour; and he that giveth alms sacrificeth praise.3To depart from wickedness is a thing pleasing to the Lord; and to forsake unrighteousness is a propitiation.4Thou shalt not appear empty before the Lord.5For all these things are to be done because of the commandment.6The offering of the righteous maketh the altar fat, and the sweet savour thereof is before the most High.7The sacrifice of a just man is acceptable. and the memorial thereof shall never be forgotten.8Give the Lord his honour with a good eye, and diminish not the firstfruits of thine hands.9In all thy gifts shew a cheerful countenance, and dedicate thy tithes with gladness.10Give unto the most High according as he hath enriched thee; and as thou hast gotten, give with a cheerful eye.11For the Lord recompenseth, and will give thee seven times as much.12Do not think to corrupt with gifts; for such he will not receive: and trust not to unrighteous sacrifices; for the Lord is judge, and with him is no respect of persons.
Sirach uses the vocabulary of the altar for the moral life. Keeping the law multiplieth offerings (v. 1), heeding the commandments is a wholesome sacrifice (v. 2), departing from injustice is a propitiatory sacrifice (v. 3), and he that doth mercy, offereth sacrifice (v. 4), to which the Greek adds "of praise." Calmet finds the Temple's whole system named in these verses: the peace-offering, the sin-offering, the oblation of fine flour and the offering of praise, which he calls the most perfect of all. Then, at verse 10, the passage turns to actual gifts, firstfruits and tithes. Give glory to God with a good heart reads literally "mind" in the Latin and "eye" in the Greek, which Haydock takes as an eye free from avarice, citing 2 Corinthians ix. 7.
The commentators keep both halves in view. Calmet's summary of the opening is "virtue is the most acceptable sacrifice," and Worthington ranks the sacrifices of penance, justice and praise before all external ones, yet Worthington also insists that external sacrifice must not be neglected, and Calmet calls the passage "the true spirit of the law." Verse 6, thou shalt not appear empty in the sight of the Lord, raises the case of the poor. Haydock holds that the poor who bring a virtuous heart are more acceptable than the rich who are buried in sin, however splendid their offerings. Calmet notes that some inferred from Exodus xxiii. 16 that the poor were rejected, and answers that this passage explains what the law meant: God requires each to give according to ability, and from someone who has nothing, keeping the commandments will satisfy Him.
This answers both the man who thinks ritual excuses injustice and the man who thinks a good heart excuses giving nothing. Sirach asks for the firstfruits of thy hands undiminished (v. 10), tithes sanctified with joy (v. 11), a gift measured by what he hath given to thee (v. 12). Calmet glosses sanctify as setting apart for the ministers and the Temple, and Worthington adds that God will reward the giver much more. The image Sirach leaves is the cheerful countenance of verse 11 and the good eye of verse 12, the giver whose eye is free from avarice.
Responsorial Psalm · Psalm 50:5-6, 7-8, 14, 23
5Gather ye together his saints to him: who set his covenant before sacrifices.6And the heavens shall declare his justice: for God is judge.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak: O Israel, and I will testify to thee: I am God, thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices: and thy burnt offerings are always in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise: and pay thy vows to the most High.23The sacrifice of praise shall glorify me: and there is the way by which I will shew him the salvation of God.
5Gather his holy ones to him, you who order his covenant above sacrifices.6And the heavens will announce his justice. For God is the judge.7Listen, my people, and I will speak. Listen, Israel, and I will testify for you. I am God, your God.8I will not reprove you for your sacrifices. Moreover, your holocausts are ever in my sight.14Offer to God the sacrifice of praise, and pay your vows to the Most High.23The sacrifice of praise will honor me. And in that place is the journey by which I will reveal to him the salvation of God.
5Gather my saints together unto me; those that have made a covenant with me by sacrifice.6And the heavens shall declare his righteousness: for God is judge himself. Selah.7Hear, O my people, and I will speak; O Israel, and I will testify against thee: I am God, even thy God.8I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices or thy burnt offerings, to have been continually before me.14Offer unto God thanksgiving; and pay thy vows unto the most High:23Whoso offereth praise glorifieth me: and to him that ordereth his conversation aright will I shew the salvation of God.
The psalm stages a trial. God summons His people, the heavens testify, and the charge turns out not to concern sacrifices at all: I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices (v. 8). Verse 5 is obscure. The Hebrew calls the gathered "my merciful ones," and the Douay's who set his covenant before sacrifices can also be rendered, as Haydock notes, "who make a covenant with him respecting sacrifices," the Protestant reading being "by sacrifice"; Menochius observes that sacrifice generally preceded a covenant. The resolution comes in the command of verse 14, Offer to God the sacrifice of praise, repeated as the psalm's last word (v. 23). Augustine stops on the word holocaust, which he explains as holon, "whole," and causis, "burning": a whole consumed with fire.
On who the gathered saints are, Calmet says the chosen people, Theodoret the priests, whom Chrysostom thinks may have valued the legal sacrifices too highly, and Eusebius all the elect. Augustine reads the gathering as the last judgment and the saints as those "that have had compassion on the needy," setting God's promises above their own works; the heavens that declare his justice (v. 6) are, for Jerome and Augustine, the Apostles and Evangelists. The commentators agree that the psalm does not abolish sacrifice by decree. Worthington and Calmet say outward sacrifices pleased God but were of no service to Him, since the whole world is His already, and that praise and a contrite heart must accompany them if they are to be acceptable. Augustine's holocaust settles the question from the inside. The holocaust always in God's sight is a mind "inflamed with love," which will not let the limbs serve cupidity, and the abandoned calves and he-goats foretold "a certain Sacrifice which was to be, with the Blood whereof we should be cleansed." Worthington, citing Augustine, sees the psalm proving that the old victims must give place to the body of Christ, and Haydock adds that Eucharist means thanksgiving, the tribute of praise God requires.
Augustine meets a poor man's fear that God will demand what he lacks: God "doth not exact what He hath not given." No one needs to go into Arabia for frankincense, because the altar is one's conscience; Zacchaeus had the sacrifice of praise in his patrimony, the widow in her bag, another man "wholly in his heart." He denies the name of praise to two counterfeits. One is the man who lives ill and speaks well. The other is the man who lives well and credits his merits, and so the publican went down justified rather than the Pharisee. Verse 23 promises the salvation of God, which Augustine identifies with Christ, shown to the sinner who copies the publican and, in his words, will "show wounds, beseech Physician."
Gospel · Mark 10:28-31
28And Peter began to say unto him: Behold, we have left all things and have followed thee.29Jesus answering said: Amen I say to you, there is no man who hath left house or brethren or sisters or father or mother or children or lands, for my sake and for the gospel,30Who shall not receive an hundred times as much, now in this time: houses and brethren and sisters and mothers and children and lands, with persecutions: and in the world to come life everlasting.31But many that are first shall be last: and the last, first.
28And Peter began to say to him, “Behold, we have left all things and have followed you.”29In response, Jesus said: “Amen I say to you, There is no one who has left behind house, or brothers, or sisters, or father, or mother, or children, or land, for my sake and for the Gospel,30who will not receive one hundred times as much, now in this time: houses, and brothers, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and land, with persecutions, and in the future age eternal life.31But many of the first shall be last, and the last shall be first.”
28Then Peter began to say unto him, Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee.29And Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my sake, and the gospel’s,30But he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions; and in the world to come eternal life.31But many that are first shall be last; and the last first.
Peter's Behold, we have left all things (v. 28) is an odd boast, and Theophylact says so: Peter had left but few things, and still calls these his all — because even a few things keep us by the bond of affection, so that he shall be beatified who leaves a few. The Gloss supplies the pressure behind the question: the rich young man had just gone away sorrowful, and the disciples, who had already done what he could not bear to hear, began to ask about their reward, thinking it a great thing. Bede notices what Peter is careful to add. It is not sufficient to have left all, so he adds what makes up perfection, and have followed thee — "as if he said, We have done what Thou hast commanded. What reward therefore wilt Thou give us?" The answer does not stay where the question was put: Peter asks only about the disciples, Theophylact observes, and the Lord replies generally, of any man who has left house or brethren for the gospel.
What the hundredfold amounts to has been fought over. Bede attacks those who read it of a thousand years after the resurrection of the just, when all that was given up is restored with interest — "that Jewish fable" — and argues textually, not merely indignantly: the other Evangelists list a hundred wives, which makes the promise's foulness plain; the Lord testifies that there is no marriage in the resurrection; and he says the restoration comes now in this time, with persecutions, which on the millenarians' own account their thousand years will not contain. The catena's own editorial note records that some early Fathers, Augustine and Irenaeus among them, did hold a doctrine of the Millennium; Bede's target is narrower than his phrasing suggests. Pseudo-Chrysostom states the alternative flatly: the reward is in participation, not possession, fulfilled spiritually and not carnally. Theophylact cashes it out in specifics: many women busied themselves about the Apostles' food and clothing, and Peter, having left one house, afterwards had the houses of all the disciples. On with persecutions Lapide offers two readings without choosing. Jerome and Bede take it that a hundred — that is, very many — will succour the persecuted man as brothers, fathers and mothers, which is marvellous because persecution is when a man is normally left destitute, everyone withdrawing for fear. Or the persecutions may themselves belong to the reward, since to suffer for Christ is a great gift of God.
The saying is easily turned into a licence, and Theophylact blocks that first: it does not mean leaving one's parents without helping them, or separating from one's wife, but preferring the glory of God to the things of this world. Chrysostom hears in the same verse a covert warning of what was coming — that many fathers would allure their sons to impiety and many wives their husbands — which is still the ordinary shape of the cost: pressure at close range, from people with a real claim on one's affection. Bede aims many that are first shall be last at the professionally religious. He daily sees men in a lay habit eminent for their meritorious life, while others ardent from youth in a spiritual profession wither away in the sloth of ease and "with a lazy folly finish in the flesh, what they had begun in the Spirit." His image for the reward is not a warning but a hand. A hundred is counted by moving from the left hand to the right; the fingers bend into the same shape they made for ten, and the quantity is enormously greater.
· sources ·
The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.
First Reading Sirach 35:1-12
And to. Greek, (4.) "He," &c. (Haydock) --- The peace-offering and that for sin, as well as the oblation of fine flour and of praise, (which is the most perfect of all) are noticed. (Calmet) --- External sacrifice must not be neglected. (Worthington)
Sacrifice. Greek adds, "of praise." (Haydock) --- This was the true spirit of the law. (Calmet)
Lord. The poor, who present a virtuous heart, are more acceptable than the rich, who are buried in sin, though the latter may offer the most splendid sacrifices. (Haydock) --- God requires that all should do according to their abilities. If they have nothing, they must fulfill the commandments, and he will be satisfied. Some have inferred from Exodus xxiii. 16., that the poor were rejected. But the meaning of the law is here explained. (Calmet)
Heart. Literally, "mind." Greek, "eye," (Haydock) free from avarice, 2 Corinthians ix. 7.
Sanctify: "set apart" for the use of the ministers, and of the temple. (Calmet) --- God will reward thee much more. (Worthington)
Responsorial Psalm Psalm 50:5-6, 7-8, 14, 23
(ver. 5). The voice divine and prophetic, seeing future things as if present doth exhort the Angels gathering. For He shall send His Angels, and before Him shall be gathered all nations. Gather to Him His righteous. What righteous men save those that live of faith and do works of mercy? For those works are works of righteousness. Thou hast the Gospel: "Beware of doing your righteousness before men to be seen of them." And as if it were inquired, What righteousness? "When therefore thou doest alms," He saith. Therefore alms He hath signified to be works of righteousness. Those very persons gather for His righteous: gather those that have had compassion on the "needy," that have considered the needy and poor: gather them, "The Lord preserve them, and make them to live;" "Gather to Him His righteous: who order His covenant above sacrifices:" that is, who think of His promises above those things which they work. For those things are sacrifices, God saying, "I will have mercy more than sacrifice." "Who keep His covenant more than sacrifice."
13. "And the Heaven shall declare His righteousness"
(ver. 6). Truly this righteousness of God to us the "heavens have declared," the Evangelists have foretold. Through them we have heard that some will be on the right hand, to whom the Householder saith, "Come, ye blessed of My Father, receive." Receive what? "A kingdom." In return for what thing? "I was an hungred, and ye gave Me to eat." What so valueless, what so earthly, as to break bread to the hungry? At so much is valued the kingdom of heaven. "Break thy bread to the hungry, and the needy without covering bring into thy house; if thou seest one naked, clothe him." If thou hast not the means of breaking bread, hast not house into which thou mayest bring, hast not garment wherewith thou mayest cover: give a cup of cold water, cast two mites into the treasury. As much the widow doth buy with two mites, as Peter buyeth, by leaving the nets, as Zacchæus buyeth by giving half his goods. Of so much worth is all that thou hast. "The heavens shall declare His righteousness, for God is Judge." Truly judge not confounding but severing. For "the Lord knoweth them that are His." Even if grains lie hid in the chaff, they are known to the husbandman. Let no one fear that he is a grain even among the chaff; the eyes of our winnower are not deceived. Fear not lest that tempest, which shall be round about Him, should confound thee with chaff. Certainly mighty will be the tempest; yet not one grain will it sweep from the side of the corn to the chaff: because not any rustic with three-pronged fork, but God, Three in One, is Judge. And the heavens shall declare His righteousness: for God is Judge. Let heavens go, let the heavens tell, into every land let their sound go out, and unto the ends of the world their words: and let that body say, "From the ends of the world unto Thee have I cried, when my heart was in heaviness." For now mingled it groaneth, divided it shall rejoice. Let it cry then and say, "Destroy not my soul with ungodly men, and with men of blood my life." He destroyeth not together, because God is Judge. Let it cry to Him and say, "Judge me, O Lord, and sever my cause from the nation unholy:" let it say, He shall do it: there shall be gathered to Him His righteous ones. He hath called the earth that He may sever His people.
14. "Hear, my people, and I will speak to thee"
(ver. 7). He shall come and shall not keep silence; see how that even now, if ye hear, He is not silent. Hear, my people, and I will speak to thee. For if thou hearest not, I will not speak to thee. "Hear, and I will speak to thee." For if thou hearest not, even though I shall speak, it will not be to thee. When then shall I speak to thee? If thou hearest. When hearest thou? If thou art my people. For, "Hear, my people:" thou hearest not if thou art an alien people. "Hear, my people, and I will speak to thee: Israel, and I will testify to thee."...For "Thy God," is properly said to that man whom God doth keep more as one of His family, as though in His household, as though in His peculiar: "Thy God am I." What wilt thou more? Requirest thou a reward from God, so that God may give thee something; so that what He hath given thee may be thine own? Behold God Himself, who shall give, is thine own. What richer than He? Gifts thou wast desiring, thou hast the Giver Himself. "God, thy God, I am."
15. What He requireth of man, let us see; what tribute our God, our Emperor and our King doth enjoin us; since He hath willed to be our King, and hath willed us to be His province? Let us hear His injunctions. Let not a poor man tremble beneath the injunction of God: what God enjoineth to be given to Himself, He doth Himself first give that enjoineth: be ye only devoted. God doth not exact what He hath not given, and to all men hath given what He doth exact. For what doth He exact? Let us hear now: "I will not reprove thee because of thy sacrifices"
(ver. 8). I will not say to thee, Wherefore hast thou not slain for me a fat bull? why hast thou not selected the best he-goat from thy flock? Wherefore doth that ram amble among thy sheep, and is not laid upon mine altar? I will not say, Examine thy fields and thy pen and thy walls, seeking what thou mayest give Me. "I will not reprove thee because of thy sacrifices." What then: Dost Thou not accept my sacrifices? "But thy holocausts are always in My sight" (ver. 9). Certain holocausts concerning which it is said in another Psalm, "If Thou hadst desired sacrifice, I would surely have given, with holocausts Thou wilt not be delighted:" and again he turneth himself, "Sacrifice to God is a troubled spirit, a heart broken and humbled God doth not despise." Which be then holocausts that He despiseth not? Which holocausts that are always in His sight? "Kindly, O Lord," he saith, "deal in Thy good will with Sion, and be the walls of Jerusalem builded, then shalt Thou accept the sacrifice of righteousness, oblations, and holocausts." He saith that certain holocausts God will accept. But what is a holocaust? A whole consumed with fire: causis is burning, holon is whole: but a "holocaust" is a whole consumed with fire. There is a certain fire of most burning love: be the mind inflamed with love, let the same love hurry off the limbs to its use, let it not allow them to serve cupidity, in order that we may wholly glow with fire of divine love that will offer to God a holocaust. Such "holocausts of thine are in My sight always."
16. As yet that Israel perchance doth not understand what are the holocausts thereof which He hath in His sight always, and is still thinking of oxen, of sheep, of he-goats: let it not so think: "I will not accept calves of thy house." Holocausts I named; at once in mind and thought to earthly flocks thou wast running, therefrom thou wast selecting for Me some fat thing: "I will not accept calves of thy house." He is foretelling the New Testament, wherein all those sacrifices have ceased. For they were then foretelling a certain Sacrifice which was to be, with the Blood whereof we should be cleansed. "I will not accept calves of thy house, nor he-goats of thy flocks."
17. "For mine are all the beasts of the wood"
(ver. 14). Let us also say to Him, "In me, O God, are thy vows, which I will render of prose to Thee." I had feared lest Thou mightest enjoin something which would be out of my power, which I was counting to be in my pen, and but now perchance it had been taken away by a thief. What dost Thou enjoin me? "Immolate to God the sacrifice of praise." Let me revert to myself, wherein I may find what I may immolate: let me revert to myself; in myself may I find immolation of praise: be Thy altar my conscience. We are without anxiety, we go not into Arabia in quest of frankincense: not any bags of covetous dealer do we sift: God requireth of us the sacrifice of praise. Zacchæus had the sacrifice of praise in his patrimony; the widow had it in her bag; some poor host or other hath had it in his jar: another neither in patrimony, nor in bag, nor in jar, hath had anything, had it wholly in his heart: salvation was to the house of Zacchæus; and more this poor widow cast in than those rich men: this man, that doth offer a cup of cold water, shall not lose his reward: but there is even "peace on earth to men of good will." "Immolate to God the sacrifice of praise." O sacrifice gratuitous, by grace given! I have not indeed bought this to offer, but Thou hast given: for not even this should I have had. And this is the immolation of the sacrifice of praise, to render thanks to Him from whom thou hast whatever of good thou hast, and by whose mercy is forgiven thee whatsoever of evil of thine thou hast. "Immolate to God the sacrifice of praise: and render to the Highest thy prayers." With this odour the Lord is well pleased.
22. "And call thou upon Me in the day of thy tribulation: and I will draw thee forth, and thou shalt glorify Me"
(ver. 23). How shall "sacrifice of praise glorify Me"? Assuredly sacrifice of praise doth no wise profit evil men, because they take Thy Covenant in their mouth, and do damnable things that displease Thine eyes. Straightway, he saith, even to them this I say, "Sacrifice of praise shall glorify Me." For if thou livest ill and speakest good words, not yet dost thou praise: but again, if, when thou beginnest to live well, to thy merits thou dost ascribe thy living well, not yet dost thou praise....Therefore the Publican went down justified, rather than that Pharisee. Therefore hear ye that live well, hear ye that live ill: "Sacrifice of praise shall glorify Me." No one offereth Me this sacrifice, and is evil. I say not, Let there not offer Me this any one that is evil; but no one doth offer Me this, that is evil. For he that praiseth, is good: because if he praiseth, he doth also live well, because if he praiseth, not only with tongue he praiseth, but life also with tongue doth agree.
31. "And there is the way whereby I will show him the salvation of God." In sacrifice of praise "is the way." What is "the salvation of God"? Christ Jesus. And how in sacrifice of praise to us is shown Christ? Because Christ with grace came to us. These words saith the Apostle: "But I live, now not I, but Christ liveth in me: but that in flesh I live, in faith I live of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave Himself for me." Acknowledge then sinners, that there would not need physician, if they were whole. For Christ died for the ungodly. When then they acknowledge their ungodlinesses, and first copy that Publican, saying, "Lord, be merciful to me a sinner:" show wounds, beseech Physician: and because they praise not themselves, but blame themselves,--"So that he that glorieth, not in himself but in the Lord may glory," --they acknowledge the cause of the coming of Christ, because for this end He came, that He might save sinners: for "Jesus Christ came," he saith, "into this world to save sinners; of whom I am chief." Further, those Jews, boasting of their work, thus the same Apostle doth rebuke, in saying, that they to grace belonged not, who to their merits and their works thought that reward was owing. He therefore that knoweth himself to belong to grace, doth know what is Christ and what is Christ's because he needeth grace. If grace it is called, gratis it is given; if gratis it is given, not any merits of time have preceded that it should be given....
His saints. Hebrew, "my merciful ones," (Haydock) the chosen people, (Calmet) particularly priests, (Theodoret) who might have too high an opinion of the legal sacrifices, (St. Chrysostom) or all the elect are meant, Matthew xxiv. 30. (Eusebius) --- The Hebrews were the only nation which then offered sacrifices to the true God, though some individuals might do it among the Gentiles. (Calmet) --- Before, super, or, "who make a covenant with him respecting sacrifices." --- Protestants, "those that have made a covenant with me by sacrifice," Malachias i. 12. (Haydock) --- The Septuagint seem to have read v for i, more accurately, as the prophet speaks till ver. 7. (Berthier) --- Judgment should begin at the house of God. And if first at us, what shall be the end of them that believe not the gospel of God? (1 Peter iv. 17., and Romans ii. 9.) (Haydock) --- Those who believe not, are already judged, John iii. --- Sacrifice generally precedes a covenant, Genesis xv. 17. (Menochius)
Heavens. Apostles, (St. Jerome) or angels. (Chaldean) (St. Athanasius) --- God is judge. His sentence must therefore be just, (Menochius) and we ought to tremble, 1 Corinthians iv. 4. (Haydock)
Testify. I will require thee to speak the truth, and attest the world, Psalm lxxx. 9. (Calmet)
Sight. I complain of no neglect (Menochius) in these outward ceremonies. (Haydock) --- God required no victims during the captivity; but he always demanded praise, (ver. 14.; Calmet) a contrite heart, Psalm l. 19., &c. (Haydock) --- The prophets often admonished the people of this truth, (Isaias i. 2., and Jeremias vii. 20.; Calmet) that they might not set too high a value on sacrifices, (Haydock) which, though pleasing to God, are of no service to him; as all the world is his property. (Worthington)
Vows. A faithless promise is very displeasing, Ecclesiastes v. 3. True religion must be interior, (Calmet) also 1 Corinthians xiv. 15. (Haydock) --- We must discharge, not only our general, (Menochius) but also our particular vows, (Worthington) and obligations. (Haydock)
Praise. This king of improper sacrifice, and those of justice, and of a contrite heart, (Psalm iv., and l.) must accompany outward sacrifices, to make them acceptable. The latter has always been obligatory, (Worthington) as well as the former. (Haydock) --- This psalm proves, that the old victims should give place to one far more excellent, the body of Christ, the sacrifice of praise which the Church offers. (St. Augustine, con. advers. xx. orat. con Jud. vi. and ep. cxx. 18.) (Worthington) --- Eucharist means "good grace," or thanksgiving, being intended to enable us to render that tribute of praise, which he requires. (Haydock) --- There. Hebrew, " to him that ordereth his conversation aright, will I," &c. (Protestants) --- The difference consists only in the points. (Berthier) --- Syriac, "There I will shew him the way of his salvation," or, according to St. Chrysostom, "even my salvation." (Calmet) --- By adoring God in spirit and truth, (Haydock) we may be saved. (Menochius)
1 The mighty God, even the Lord , hath spoken, and called the earth from the rising of the sun unto the going down thereof. 2 Out of Zion, the perfection of beauty, God hath shined. 3 Our God shall come, and shall not keep silence: a fire shall devour before him, and it shall be very tempestuous round about him. 4 He shall call to the heavens from above, and to the earth, that he may judge his people. 5 Gather my saints together unto me; those that have made a covenant with me by sacrifice. 6 And the heavens shall declare his righteousness: for God is judge himself. Selah.
It is probable that Asaph was not only the chief musician, who was to put a tune to this psalm, but that he was himself the penman of it; for we read that in Hezekiah's time they praised God in the words of David and of Asaph the seer, 2 Chron. xxix. 30 . Here is,
I. The court called, in the name of the King of kings ( v. 2 ): The mighty God, even the Lord, hath spoken —El, Elohim, Jehovah, the God of infinite power justice and mercy, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. God is the Judge, the Son of God came for judgement into the world, and the Holy Ghost is the Spirit of judgment. All the earth is called to attend, not only because the controversy God had with his people Israel for their hypocrisy and ingratitude might safely be referred to any man of reason (nay, let the house of Israel itself judge between God and his vineyard, Isa. v. 3 ), but because all the children of men are concerned to know the right way of worshipping God, in spirit and in truth, because when the kingdom of the Messiah should be set up all should be instructed in the evangelical worship, and invited to join in it (see Mal. i. 11 , Acts x. 34 ), and because in the day of final judgment all nations shall be gathered together to receive their doom, and every man shall give an account of himself unto God.
II. The judgment set, and the Judge taking his seat. As, when God gave the law to Israel in the wilderness, it is said, He came from Sinai, and rose up from Seir, and shone forth from Mount Paran, and came with ten thousands of his saints, and then from his right hand went a fiery law ( Deut. xxxiii. 2 ), so, with allusion to that, when God comes to reprove them for their hypocrisy, and to send forth his gospel to supersede the legal institutions, it is said here, 1. That he shall shine out of Zion, as then from the top of Sinai, v. 2 . Because in Zion his oracle was now fixed, thence his judgments upon that provoking people denounced, and thence the orders issued for the execution of them ( Joel ii. 1 ): Blow you the trumpet in Zion. Sometimes there are more than ordinary appearances of God's presence and power working with and by his word and ordinances, for the convincing of men's consciences and the reforming and refining of his church; and then God, who always dwells in Zion, may be said to shine out of Zion. Moreover, he may be said to shine out of Zion because the gospel, which set up spiritual worship, was to go forth from Mount Zion ( Isa. ii. 3 , Mic. iv. 2 ), and the preachers of it were to begin at Jerusalem ( Luke xxiv. 47 ), and Christians are said to come unto Mount Zion, to receive their instructions, Heb. xii. 22 , 28 . Zion is here called the perfection of beauty, because it was the holy hill; and holiness is indeed the perfection of beauty. 2. That he shall come, and not keep silence, shall no longer seem to wink at the sins of men, as he had done ( v. 21 ), but shall show his displeasure at them, and shall also cause that mystery to be published to the world by his holy apostles which had long lain hid, that the Gentiles should be fellow-heirs ( Eph. iii. 5, 6 ) and that the partition-wall of the ceremonial law should be taken down; this shall now no longer be concealed. In the great day our God shall come and shall not keep silence, but shall make those to hear his judgment that would not hearken to his law. 3. That his appearance should be very majestic and terrible: A fire shall devour before him. The fire of his judgments shall make way for the rebukes of his word, in order to the awakening of the hypocritical nation of the Jews, that the sinners in Zion, being afraid of that devouring fire ( Isa. xxxiii. 14 ), might be startled out of their sins. When his gospel kingdom was to be set up Christ came to send fire on the earth, Luke xii. 49 . The Spirit was given in cloven tongues as of fire, introduced by a rushing mighty wind, which was very tempestuous, Acts ii. 2, 3 . And in the last judgment Christ shall come in flaming fire, 2 Thess. i. 8 . See Dan. vii. 9 ; Heb. x. 27 . 4. That as on Mount Sinai he came with ten thousands of his saints, so he shall now call to the heavens from above, to take notice of this solemn process ( v. 4 ), as Moses often called heaven and earth to witness against Israel ( Deut. iv. 26 ; xxxi. 28, xxxii. 1 ), and God by his prophets, Isa. i. 2 ; Mic. vi. 2 . The equity of the judgment of the great day will be attested and applauded by heaven and earth, by saints and angels, even all the holy myriads.
III. The parties summoned ( v. 5 ): Gather my saints together unto me. This may be understood either, 1. Of saints indeed: "Let them be gathered to God through Christ; let the few pious Israelites be set by themselves;" for to them the following denunciations of wrath do not belong; rebukes to hypocrites ought not to be terrors to the upright. When God will reject the services of those that only offered sacrifice, resting in the outside of the performance, he will graciously accept those who, in sacrificing, make a covenant with him, and so attend to and answer the end of the institution of sacrifices. The design of the preaching of the gospel, and the setting up of Christ's kingdom, was to gather together in one the children of God, John xi. 52 . And at the second coming of Jesus Christ all his saints shall be gathered together unto him ( 2 Thess. ii. 1 ) to be assessors with him in the judgment; for the saints shall judge the world, 1 Cor. vi. 2 . Now it is here given as a character of the saints that they have made a covenant with God by sacrifice. Note, (1.) Those only shall be gathered to God as his saints who have, in sincerity, covenanted with him, who have taken him to be their God and given up themselves to him to be his people, and thus have joined themselves unto the Lord. (2.) It is only by sacrifice, by Christ the great sacrifice (from whom all the legal sacrifices derived what value they had), that we poor sinners can covenant with God so as to be accepted of him. There must be an atonement made for the breach of the first covenant before we can be admitted again into covenant. Or, 2. It may be understood of saints in profession, such as the people of Israel were, who are called a kingdom of priests and a holy nation, Exod. xix. 6 . They were, as a body politic, taken into covenant with God, the covenant of peculiarity; and it was done with great solemnity, by sacrifice, Exod. xxiv. 8 . "Let them come and hear what God has to say to them; let them receive the reproofs God sends them now by his prophets, and the gospel he will, in due time, send them by his Son, which shall supersede the ceremonial law. If these be slighted, let them expect to hear from God another way, and to be judged by that word which they will not be ruled by."
7 Hear, O my people, and I will speak; O Israel, and I will testify against thee: I am God, even thy God. 8 I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices or thy burnt offerings, to have been continually before me. 9 I will take no bullock out of thy house, nor he goats out of thy folds. 10 For every beast of the forest is mine, and the cattle upon a thousand hills. 11 I know all the fowls of the mountains: and the wild beasts of the field are mine. 12 If I were hungry, I would not tell thee: for the world is mine, and the fulness thereof. 13 Will I eat the flesh of bulls, or drink the blood of goats? 14 Offer unto God thanksgiving; and pay thy vows unto the most High: 15 And call upon me in the day of trouble: I will deliver thee, and thou shalt glorify me.
God is here dealing with those that placed all their religion in the observances of the ceremonial law, and thought those sufficient.
I. He lays down the original contract between him and Israel, in which they had avouched him to be their God, and he them to be his people, and so both parties were agreed ( v. 7 ): Hear, O my people! and I will speak. Note, It is justly expected that whatever others doe, when he speaks, his people should give ear; who will, if they do not? And then we may comfortably expect that God will speak to us when we are ready to hear what he says; even when he testifies against us in the rebukes and threatenings of his word and providences we must be forward to hear what he says, to hear even the rod and him that has appointed it.
II. He puts a slight upon the legal sacrifices, v. 8 , &c. Now,
1. This may be considered as looking back to the use of these under the law. God had a controversy with the Jews; but what was the ground of the controversy? Not their neglect of the ceremonial institutions; no, they had not been wanting in the observance of them, their burnt-offerings had been continually before God, they took a pride in them, and hoped by their offerings to procure a dispensation for their lusts, as the adulterous woman, Prov. vii. 14 . Their constant sacrifices, they thought, would both expiate and excuse their neglect of the weightier matters of the law. Nay, if they had, in some degree, neglected these institutions, yet that should not have been the cause of God's quarrel with them, for it was but a small offence in comparison with the immoralities of their conversation. They thought God was mightily beholden to them for the many sacrifices they had brought to his altar, and that they had made him very much their debtor by them, as if he could not h have maintained his numerous family of priests without their contributions; but God here shows them the contrary, (1.) That he did not need their sacrifices. What occasion had he for their bullocks and goats who has the command of all the beasts of the forest, and the cattle upon a thousand hills ( v. 9, 10 ), has an incontestable propriety in them and dominion over them, has them all always under his eye and within his reach, and can make what use he pleases of them; they all wait on him, and are all at his disposal? Ps. civ. 27-29 . Can we add any thing to his store whose all the wild fowl and wild beasts are, the world itself and the fulness thereof? v. 11, 12 . God's infinite self-sufficiency proves our utter insufficiency to add any thing to him. (2.) That he could not be benefited by their sacrifices. Their goodness, of this kind, could not possibly extend to him, nor, if they were in this matter righteous, was he the better ( v. 13 ): Will I eat the flesh of bulls? It is as absurd to think that their sacrifices could, of themselves, and by virtue of any innate excellency in them, add any pleasure of praise to God, as it would be to imagine that an infinite Spirit could be supported by meat and drink, as our bodies are. It is said indeed of the demons whom the Gentiles worshipped that they did eat the fat of their sacrifices, and drink the wine of their drink-offerings ( Deut. xxxii. 38 ): they regaled themselves in the homage they robbed the true God of; but will the great Jehovah be thus entertained? No; to obey is better than sacrifice, and to love God and our neighbour better than all burnt-offerings, so much better that God by his prophets often told them that their sacrifices were not only not acceptable, but abominable, to him, while they lived in sin; instead of pleasing him, he looked upon them as a mockery, and therefore an affront and provocation to him; see Prov. xv. 8; Isa. i. 11, &c. ; lxvi. 3 ; Jer. vi. 20 ; Amos v. 21 . They are therefore here warned not to rest in these performances; but to conduct themselves, in all other instances, towards God as their God.
2. This may be considered as looking forward to the abolishing of these by the gospel of Christ. Thus Dr. Hammond understands it. When God shall set up the kingdom of the Messiah he shall abolish the old way of worship by sacrifice and offerings; he will no more have those to be continually before him ( v. 8 ); he will no more require of his worshippers to bring him their bullocks and their goats, to be burnt upon his altar, v. 9 . For indeed he never appointed this as that which he had any need of, or took any pleasure in, for, besides that all we have is his already, he has far more beasts in the forest and upon the mountains, which we know nothing of nor have any property in, than we have in our folds; but he instituted it to prefigure the great sacrifice which his own Son should in the fulness of time offer upon the cross, to make atonement for sin, and all the other spiritual sacrifices of acknowledgment with which God, through Christ, will be well pleased.
16 But unto the wicked God saith, What hast thou to do to declare my statutes, or that thou shouldest take my covenant in thy mouth? 17 Seeing thou hatest instruction, and castest my words behind thee. 18 When thou sawest a thief, then thou consentedst with him, and hast been partaker with adulterers. 19 Thou givest thy mouth to evil, and thy tongue frameth deceit. 20 Thou sittest and speakest against thy brother; thou slanderest thine own mother's son. 21 These things hast thou done, and I kept silence; thou thoughtest that I was altogether such an one as thyself: but I will reprove thee, and set them in order before thine eyes. 22 Now consider this, ye that forget God, lest I tear you in pieces, and there be none to deliver. 23 Whoso offereth praise glorifieth me: and to him that ordereth his conversation aright will I show the salvation of God.
God, by the psalmist, having instructed his people in the right way of worshipping him and keeping up their communion with him, here directs his speech to the wicked, to hypocrites, whether they were such as professed the Jewish or the Christian religion: hypocrisy is wickedness for which God will judge. Observe here,
I. The charge drawn up against them. 1. They are charged with invading and usurping the honours and privileges of religion ( v. 16 ): What has thou to do, O wicked man! to declare my statutes? This is a challenge to those that rare really profane, but seemingly godly, to show what title they have to the cloak of religion, and by what authority they wear it, when they use it only to cover and conceal the abominable impieties of their hearts and lives. Let them make out their claim to it if they can. Some think it points prophetically at the scribes and Pharisees that were the teachers and leaders of the Jewish church at the time when the kingdom of the Messiah, and that evangelical way of worship spoken of in the foregoing verses , were to be set up. They violently opposed that great revolution, and used all the power and interest which they had by sitting in Moses's seat to hinder it; but the account which our blessed Saviour gives of them ( Matt. xxiii .), and St. Paul ( Rom. ii. 21, 22 ), makes this expostulation here agree very well to them. They took on them to declare God's statues, but they hated Christ's instruction; and therefore what had they to do to expound the law, when they rejected the gospel? But it is applicable to all those that are practicers of iniquity, and yet professors of piety, especially if withal they be preachers of it. Note, It is very absurd in itself, and a great affront to the God of heaven, for those that are wicked and ungodly to declare his statutes and to take his covenant in their mouths. It is very possible, and too common, for those that declare God's statutes to others to live in disobedience to them themselves, and for those that take God's covenant in their mouths yet in their hearts to continue their covenant with sin and death; but they are guilty of a usurpation, they take to themselves an honour which they have no title to, and there is a day coming when they will be thrust out as intruders. Friend, how camest thou in hither? 2. They are charged with transgressing and violating the laws and precepts of religion. (1.) They are charged with a daring contempt of the word of God ( v. 17 ): Thou hatest instruction. They loved to give instruction, and to tell others what they should do, for this fed their pride and made them look great, and by this craft they got their living; but they hated to receive instruction from God himself, for that would be a check upon them and a mortification to them. "Thou hatest discipline, the reproofs of the word and the rebukes of Providence." No wonder that those who hate to be reformed hate the means of reformation. Thou castest my words behind thee. They seemed to set God's words before them, when they sat in Moses's seat, and undertook to teach others out of the law ( Rom. ii. 19 ); but in their conversations they cast God's word behind them, and did not care for seeing that rule which they were resolved not to be ruled by. This is despising the commandment of the Lord. (2.) A close confederacy with the worst of sinners ( v. 18 ): " When thou sawest a thief, instead of reproving him and witnessing against him, as those should do that declare God's statutes, thou consentedst with him, didst approve of his practices, and desire to be a partner with him and to share in the profits of his cursed trade; and thou hast been partaker with adulterers, hast done as they did, and encouraged them to go on in their wicked courses, hast done these things and hast had pleasure in those that do them, " Rom. i. 32 . (3.) A constant persisting in the worst of tongue-sins ( v. 19 ): " Thou givest thy mouth to evil, not only allowest thyself in, but addictest thyself wholly to, all manner of evil-speaking." [1.] Lying: Thy tongue frames deceit, which denotes contrivance and deliberation in lying. It knits or links deceit, so some. One lie begets another, and one fraud requires another to cover it. [2.] Slandering ( v. 20 ): " Thou sittest, and speakest against thy brother, dost basely abuse and misrepresent him, magisterially judge and censure him, and pass sentence upon him, as if you wert his master to whom he must stand or fall, whereas he is thy brother, as good as thou art, and upon the level with thee, for he is thy own mother's son. He is thy near relation, whom thou oughtest to love, to vindicate, and stand up for, if others abused him; yet thou dost thyself abuse him, whose faults thou oughtest to cover and make the best of; if really he had done amiss, yet thou dost most falsely and unjustly charge him with that which he is innocent of; thou sittest and doest this, as a judge upon the bench, with authority; thou sittest in the seat of the scornful, to deride and backbite those whom thou oughtest to respect and be kind to." Those that do ill themselves commonly delight in speaking ill of others.
II. The proof of this charge ( v. 21 ): " These things thou hast done; the fact is too plain to be denied, the fault too bad to be excused; these things God knows, and thy own heart knows, thou hast done." The sins of sinners will be proved upon them, beyond contradiction, in the judgment of the great day: " I will reprove thee, or convince thee, so that thou shalt have not one word to say for thyself." The day is coming when impenitent sinners will have their mouths for ever stopped and be struck speechless. What confusion will they be filled with when God shall set their sins in order before their eyes! They would not see their sins to their humiliation, but cast them behind their backs, covered them, and endeavoured to forget them, nor would they suffer their own consciences to put them in mind of them; but the day is coming when God will make them see their sins to their everlasting shame and terror; he will set them in order, original sin, actual sins, sins against the law, sins against the gospel, against the first table, against the second table, sins of childhood and youth, of riper age, and old age. He will set them in order, as the witnesses are set in order, and called in order, against the criminal, and asked what they have to say against him.
III. The Judge's patience, and the sinner's abuse of that patience: " I kept silence, did not give thee any disturbance in thy sinful way, but let thee alone to take thy course; sentence against thy evil works was respited, and not executed speedily." Note, The patience of God is very great towards provoking sinners. He sees their sins and hates them; it would be neither difficulty nor damage to him to punish them, and yet he waits to be gracious and gives them space to repent, that he may render them inexcusable if they repent not. His patience is the more wonderful because the sinner makes such an ill use of it: " Thou thoughtest that I was altogether such a one as thyself, as weak and forgetful as thyself, as false to my word as thyself, nay, as much a friend to sin as thyself." Sinners take God's silence for consent and his patience for connivance; and therefore the longer they are reprieved the more are their hearts hardened; but, if they turn not, they shall be made to see their error when it is too late, and that the God they provoke is just, and holy, and terrible, and not such a one as themselves.
IV. The fair warning given of the dreadful doom of hypocrites ( v. 22 ): " Now consider this, you that forget God, consider that God knows and keeps account of all your sins, that he will call you to an account for them, that patience abused will turn into the greater wrath, that though you forget God and your duty to him he will not forget you and your rebellions against him: consider this in time, before it be too late; for if these things be not considered, and the consideration of them improved, he will tear you in pieces, and there will be none to deliver. " It is the doom of hypocrites to be cut asunder, Matt. xxiv. 51 . Note, 1. Forgetfulness of God is at the bottom of all the wickedness of the wicked. Those that know God, and yet do not obey him, do certainly forget him. 2. Those that forget God forget themselves; and it will never be right with them till they consider, and so recover themselves. Consideration is the first step towards conversion. 3. Those that will not consider the warnings of God's word will certainly be torn in pieces by the executions of his wrath. 4. When God comes to tear sinners in pieces, there is no delivering them out of his hand. They cannot deliver themselves, nor can any friend they have in the world deliver them.
V. Full instructions given to us all how to prevent this fearful doom. Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter; we have it, v. 23 , which directs us what to do that we may attain our chief end. 1. Man's chief end is to glorify God, and we are here told that whoso offers praise glorifies him; whether he be Jew or Gentile, those spiritual sacrifices shall be accepted from him. We must praise God, and we must sacrifice praise, direct it to God, as every sacrifice was directed; put it into the hands of the priest, our Lord Jesus, who is also the altar; see that it be made by fire, sacred fire, that it be kindled with the flame of holy and devout affection; we must be fervent in spirit, praising the Lord. This he is pleased, in infinite condescension, to interpret as glorifying him. Hereby we give him the glory due to his name and do what we can to advance the interests of his kingdom among men. 2. Man's chief end, in conjunction with this, is to enjoy God; and we are here told that those who order their conversation aright shall see his salvation. (1.) It is not enough for us to offer praise, but we must withal order our conversation aright. Thanksgiving is good, but thanks-living is better. (2.) Those that would have their conversation right must take care and pains to order it, to dispose it according to rule, to understand their way and to direct it. (3.) Those that take care of their conversation make sure their salvation; them God will make to see his salvation, for it is a salvation ready to be revealed; he will make them to see it and enjoy it, to see it, and to see themselves happy for ever in it. Note, The right ordering of the conversation is the only way, and it is a sure way, to obtain the great salvation.
5. my saints-- ( Psa 4:3 ).
made-- literally, "cut"
a covenant, &c.-- alluding to the dividing of a victim of sacrifice, by which covenants were ratified, the parties passing between the divided portions (compare Ge 15:10 , 18 ).
6. The inhabitants of heaven, who well know God's character, attest His righteousness as a judge.
7. I will testify-- that is, for failure to worship aught.
thy God-- and so, by covenant as well as creation, entitled to a pure worship.
8-15. However scrupulous in external worship, it was offered as if they conferred an obligation in giving God His own, and with a degrading view of Him as needing it [Psa 50:9-13]. Reproving them for such foolish and blasphemous notions, He teaches them to offer, or literally, "sacrifice," thanksgiving, and pay, or perform, their vows-- that is, to bring, with the external symbolical service, the homage of the heart, and faith, penitence, and love. To this is added an invitation to seek, and a promise to afford, all needed help in trouble.
23. offereth praise-- ( Psa 50:14 ), so that the external worship is a true index of the heart.
Gospel Mark 10:28-31
CHAPTER 10
2 Christ disputeth with the Pharisees touching divorcement: 13 blesseth the children that are brought unto him: 17 resolveth a rich man how he may inherit life everlasting: 23 telleth his disciples of the danger of riches: 28 promiseth rewards to them that forsake anything for the gospel: 32 foretelleth his death and resurrection: 35 biddeth the two ambitious suitors to think rather of suffering with him: 46 and restoreth to Bartimæus his sight.
Ver. 21. And Jesus regarding him, with a benignant and pleasant countenance, loved him, showed him marks of His love, taking his hand and smiling upon him, embracing and kissing him.
One thing is wanting unto thee, namely, for the perfection of a holy and evangelical life.
Follow Me. The Greek adds, Taking up thy cross. The Syriac has, Take thy cross, and come after Me.
Ver. 24. Little children (Vulg.); the Syriac, My sons. By His bland address He softens the hardness of the matter. He is like one who loves his children most dearly; and as such He would tell them the truth in sincerity, and persuade them to renounce riches as a bar to salvation.
That trust in riches. For rich men trust in their riches rather than in God, according to the saying in Proverbs (Pro_10:15), "The substance of a rich man is the city of his strength" (Vulg.). With difficulty, therefore, are they saved, because salvation cometh only from God. Wherefore those who wish to be saved must put their trust in God, and must ask and wait for salvation from Him, as the poor do. For inasmuch as they have no riches in which to trust, they are obliged to place all their hopes in God, according to the words (Psa_14:6), "Ye have shamed the counsel of the poor, because the Lord is his hope." Therefore if rich men wish to be saved, let them turn their hope, their heart, their love from riches, and fix them upon God.
Ver. 30. Who shall not receive an hundred times as much, now in this time; houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions: and in the world to come life everlasting. I have explained this hundredfold in S. Mat_19:29. Mark here adds, with persecutions. The Arabic has, in tribulations. "Let him who has relinquished his possessions and friends for the love of Christ, and is set in the midst of persecutions, and is encompassed by them on every side, be faithful. For there will not be wanting a hundred, that is, very many, who will succour and cherish him, as brothers, fathers, and mothers." So Jerome, Bede, &c.
This is added because in persecutions the believer especially needs the help and assistance of others. Also, because this is a rare and marvellous thing, that in persecution, when a man is wont to be left destitute of help and friends, and when all, through fear of danger, withdraw themselves from him, those who follow Christ experience the exact contrary, and find a hundred, i.e., very many to succour them.
Again, with persecutions may be taken thusthat persecutions and tribulations undergone for Christ's sake reward which shall be given, together with the hundredfold, to those who follow Christ. For to suffer for Christ is a great gift of God, as the Apostle teaches (Phi_2:19).
Ver. 32. They were in the way, from Jericho, . . . and Jesus went before them, as with alacrity, affording himself as a guide in the way to the frightened Apostles, who shrank from Jerusalem, because they knew that Jesus was there sought for by the princes to be put to death. Yea, a decree had been made to that effect by their great council, the Sanhedrin (Joh_11:52). Whence it follows
They were astonished, and following, were afraid. Gr. ε̉θαμβου̃ντο, i.e., they were astonished with great fear and dread. The imminent peril of death, says Bede, was the cause of their fear. They were amazed that Christ with so prompt and resolute a mind should bring Himself and His disciples into such open peril of death. They were afraid lest they might suffer and be put to death with Christ.
Ver. 38. Or be baptised with the baptism wherewith I am baptized. Christ calls His Passion a baptism, because He was to be evidently immersed and drowned in it, according to what David says of himself, but much more of Christ (Psa_69:12), "Save me, 0 God; for the waters are come in unto my soul. I sink in deep mire, where there is no standing: I am come into deep waters, where the floods overflow me."
Ver. 42. Ye know that they who seem to rule over the Gentiles lord it over them. Gr. κατακυριεύουσιν αυ̉τω̃ν, i.e, dominate over them, or against them. For who seem, the Gr. is οί δοκου̃ντες, i.e., who please themselves, and rejoice in ruling. For none rule more imperiously and harshly than those who are delighted with ruling and commanding. Whence the Arabic translates, they who think themselves princes of the people are their lords, i.e., they exercise, as it were, a tyrannical domination over them.
Ver. 46. Bartimæus, the son of Timæus. This blind man, then, was called by a proper name, Bartimæus, i.e., the son of Timæus, as Bartholomew is the same as son of Ptolemy. The same was called also by the same name as his father Timæus. Timæus was the name of that Pythagorean philosopher who wrote the life of Pythagoras.
Moreover, Bartimæus is interpreted by Pagnini in three ways (in Nom. Hebraicis). The first is from S. Jerome, to the effect that Bartimæus means the blind son, or the son of blindness. He says that it is a Syriac name, but corrupted from Barsemia, or Barsamæus. Bar is son, semaia, blindness.
The second opinion is, that it means the son of honour; as if compounded of the Syriac bar, a son, and the Gr. τιμή, honour.
The third is, that it means the son of the admirer, or admirable corn, or admirable purity. For this was what the blind man received from Christ. For being illuminated in body, he was far more illuminated in his soul. For bar means meal, or wheat, or purity, as well as son. Tamah is to admire.
And followed Him in the way. Moraliter: Says the Gloss, Let us consider the way in which He goeth, and follow Him by humility and labours. The way is that of which He saith, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." This is "the narrow way," which leads to the heights of Jerusalem and Bethany, to the Mount of Olives, which is the mount of light and consolation; yea, which leads to Zion and the heavenly Jerusalem. The blind man therefore sees and follows, for he who rightly understands the life of Christ ought to follow and imitate it by his works. (Top)
Then Peter began to say unto him, "Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee."29. And Jesus answered and said, "Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for My sake, and the Gospel’s,30. But he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions; and in the world to come eternal life.31. But many that are first shall be last; and the last first."
Because the youth, on hearing the advice of our Saviour concerning the casting away of his goods, had gone away sorrowful, the disciples of Christ, who had already fulfilled the foregoing precept, began to question Him concerning their reward, thinking that they had done a great thing, since the young man, who had fulfilled the commandments of the law, had not been able to hear it without sadness.
Wherefore Peter questions the Lord for himself and the others, in these words, "Then Peter began to say unto Him, Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee."
Although Peter had left but few things, still he calls these his all; for even a few things keep us by the bond of affection, so that he shall be beatified who leaves a few things.
And because it is not sufficient to have left all, he adds that which makes up perfection, "and have followed thee." As if he said, We have done what Thou hast commanded. What reward therefore wilt Thou give us?
But while Peter asks only concerning the disciples, our Lord makes a general answer; wherefore it goes on: "Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no one that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or children, or lands." But in saying this, He does not mean that we should leave our fathers, without helping them, or that we should separate ourselves from our wives; but He instructs us to prefer the glory of God to the things of this world.
But it seems to me that by these words He intended covertly to proclaim that there were to be persecutions, as it would come to pass that many fathers would allure their sons to impiety, and many wives their husbands.
Again He delays not to say, "for my name’s sake and the Gospel’s" and Mark says, or "for the kingdom of God," as Luke says; the name of Christ is the power of the Gospel, and of His kingdom; for the Gospel is received in the name of Jesus Christ, and the kingdom is made known, and comes by His name.
Some, however, taking occasion from this saying, in which it is announced that he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, teach that Jewish fable of a thousand years after the resurrection of the just, when all that we have left for the Lord’s sake is to be restored with manifold usury, besides which we are to receive the crown of everlasting life. These persons do no perceive, that although the promise in other respects be honourable, yet in the hundred wives, which the other Evangelists mention, its foulness is made manifest: particularly when the Lord testifies that there shall be not marriage in the resurrection, and asserts that those things which are put away from us for His sake are to be received again in this life with persecutions, which, as they affirm, will not take place in their thousand years. (ed. note: Certain early Fathers, as, for instance, St. Austin and Irenaeus, held the doctrine of the Millennium; Bede however mentions the Chilliasts (though their name is omitted in the Catena) and thus shews that he means the Corinthians, to whom that name was applied, on account of their shocking doctrine, that after the resurrection the Christians were to reign on earth for a thousand years in sensual pleasures, see Aug, de. Her. 8)
This hundredfold reward therefore must be in participation, not in possession, for the Lord fulfilled this to them not carnally, but spiritually.
For a wife is busied in a house about her husband’s food and raiment. See also how this is the case with the Apostles; for many women busied themselves about their food and their clothing, and ministered unto them. In like manner the Apostles had many fathers and mothers, that is, persons who loved them; as Peter, for instance, leaving one house, had afterwards the houses of all the disciples. And what is more wonderful, they are to be persecuted and oppressed, for it is "with persecutions" that the Saints are to possess all things, for which reason there follows, "But many that are first shall be last, and the last first." For the Pharisees who were first became the last; but those who left all and followed Christ were last in this world through tribulation and persecutions, but shall be first by the hope which is in God.
This which is here said, "shall receive an hundredfold," may be understood in a higher sense. For the number a hundred which is reckoned by changing from the left to the right hand, although it has the same appearance in the bending of the fingers as the ten had on the left, nevertheless is increased to a much greater quantity. This means, that all who have despised temporal things for the sake of the kingdom of heaven through undoubting faith, taste the joy of the same kingdom in this life which is full of persecutions, and in the expectation of the heavenly country, which is signified by the right hand, have a share in the happiness of all the elect. But because all do not accomplish a virtuous course of life with the same ardour as they began it, it is presently added, "But many that are first shall be last, and the last first"; for we daily see many persons who, remaining in a lay habit, are eminent for their meritorious life; but others, who from their youth have been ardent in a spiritual profession, at last wither away in the sloth of ease, and with a lazy folly finish in the flesh, what they had begun in the Spirit.
Although St. Peter had left but few things, he still calls them his all. For small things have power of attaching us to them, and of exciting our passions; therefore he that forsakes his small possessions, shall be a partaker of the blessings of Jesus Christ. (Theophylactus)
17 And when he was gone forth into the way, there came one running, and kneeled to him, and asked him, Good Master, what shall I do that I may inherit eternal life? 18 And Jesus said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God. 19 Thou knowest the commandments, Do not commit adultery, Do not kill, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Defraud not, Honour thy father and mother. 20 And he answered and said unto him, Master, all these have I observed from my youth. 21 Then Jesus beholding him loved him, and said unto him, One thing thou lackest: go thy way, sell whatsoever thou hast, and give to the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven: and come, take up the cross, and follow me. 22 And he was sad at that saying, and went away grieved: for he had great possessions. 23 And Jesus looked round about, and saith unto his disciples, How hardly shall they that have riches enter into the kingdom of God! 24 And the disciples were astonished at his words. But Jesus answereth again, and saith unto them, Children, how hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God! 25 It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God. 26 And they were astonished out of measure, saying among themselves, Who then can be saved? 27 And Jesus looking upon them saith, With men it is impossible, but not with God: for with God all things are possible. 28 Then Peter began to say unto him, Lo, we have left all, and have followed thee. 29 And Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my sake, and the gospel's, 30 But he shall receive a hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands, with persecutions; and in the world to come eternal life. 31 But many that are first shall be last; and the last first.
I. Here is a hopeful meeting between Christ and a young man; such he is said to be ( Matt. xix. 20 , 22 ), and a ruler ( Luke xviii. 18 ), a person of quality. Some circumstances here are, which we had not in Matthew, which makes his address to Christ very promising.
1. He came running to Christ, which was an indication of his humility; he laid aside the gravity and grandeur of a ruler, when he came to Christ: thus too he manifested his earnestness and importunity; he ran as one in haste, and longing to be in conversation with Christ. He had now an opportunity of consulting this great Prophet, in the things that belonged to his peace, and he would not let slip the opportunity.
2. He came to him when he was in the way, in the midst of company: he did not insist upon a private conference with him by night, as Nicodemus did, though like him he was a ruler, but when he shall find him without, will embrace that opportunity of advising with him, and not be ashamed, Cant. viii. 1 .
3. He kneeled to him, in token of the great value and veneration he had for him, as a teacher come from God, and his earnest desire to be taught by him. He bowed the knee to the Lord Jesus, as one that would not only do obeisance to him now, but would yield obedience to him always; he bowed the knee, as one that meant to bow the soul to him.
4. His address to him was serious and weighty; Good Master, what shall I do, that I may inherit eternal life? Eternal life was an article of his creed, though then denied by the Sadducees, a prevailing party: he asks, What shall he do now that he may be happy for ever. Most men enquire for good to be had in this world ( Ps. iv. 6 ), any good; he asks for good to be done in this world, in order to the enjoyment of the greatest good in the other world; not, Who will make us to see good? But, "Who will make us to do good? " He enquires for happiness in the way of duty; the summum bonum—chief good which Solomon was in quest of, was that good for the sons of men which they do should do, Eccl. ii. 3 . Now this was, (1.) A very serious question in itself; it was about eternal things, and his own concern in those things. Note, Then there begins to be some hope of people, when they begin to enquire solicitously, what they shall do to get to heaven. (2.) It was proposed to a right person, one that was every way fit to answer it, being himself the Way, the Truth, and the Life, the true way to life, to eternal life; who came from heaven on purpose, first to lay open for us, and then to lay open to us; first to make, and then to make known, the way to heaven. Note, Those who would know what they shall do to be saved, must apply themselves to Christ, and enquire of him; it is peculiar to the Christian religion, both to show eternal life, and to show the way to it. (3.) It was proposed with a good design—to be instructed. We find this same question put by a lawyer, not kneeling, but standing up ( Luke x. 25 ), with a bad design, to pick quarrels with him; he tempted him, saying, Master, what shall I do? It is not so much the good words as the good intention of them that Christ looks at.
5. Christ encouraged this address, (1.) By assisting his faith, v. 18 . He called him good Master; Christ would have him mean thereby, that he looked upon him to be God, since there is none good but one, that is God, who is one, and his name one, Zech. xiv. 9 . Our English word God doubtless hath affinity with good; as the Hebrews name God by his power, Elohim, the strong God; so we by his goodness, the good God. (2.) By directing his practice ( v. 19 ); Keep the commandments; and thou knowest what they are. He mentions the six commandments of the second table, which prescribe our duty to our neighbour; he inverts the order, putting the seventh commandment before the sixth, to intimate that adultery is a sin no less heinous than murder itself. The fifth commandment is here put last, as that which should especially be remembered and observed, to keep us to all the rest. Instead of the tenth commandment, Thou shalt not covet, our Saviour here puts, Defraud not. Me apostereses —that is, saith Dr. Hammond, "Thou shalt not rest contented with thy own, and not seek to increase it by the diminution of other men's." It is a rule of justice not to advance or enrich ourselves by doing wrong or injury to any other.
6. The young man bid fair for heaven, having been free from any open gross violations of the divine commands. Thus far he was able to same in some measure ( v. 20 ), Master, all these have I observed from my youth. He thought he had, and his neighbours thought so too. Note, Ignorance of the extent and spiritual nature of the divine law, makes people think themselves in a better condition than they really are. Paul was alive without the law. But when he saw that to be spiritual, he saw himself to be carnal, Rom. vii. 9 , 14 . However, he that could say he was free from scandalous sin, went further than many in the way to eternal life. But though we know nothing by ourselves, yet are we not thereby justified. 1 Cor. iv. 4 .
7. Christ had a kindness for him; Jesus, beholding him, loved him, v. 21 . He was pleased to find that he had lived inoffensively, and pleased to see that he was inquisitive how to live better than so. Christ particularly loves to see young people, and rich people, asking the way to heaven, with their faces thitherward.
II. Here is a sorrowful parting between Christ and this young man.
1. Christ gave him a command of trial, by which it would appear whether he did in sincerity aim at eternal life, and press towards it: he seemed to have his heart much upon it, and if so, he is what he should be; but has he indeed his heart upon it? Bring him to the touchstone. (1.) Can he find in his heart to part with his riches for the service of Christ? He hath a good estate, and now, shortly, at the first founding of the Christian church, the necessity of the case will require that those who have lands, sell them, and lay the money at the apostles' feet; and how will he dispense with that? Acts iv. 34, 35 . After awhile, tribulation and persecution will arise, because of the word; and he must be forced to sell his estate, or have it taken from him, and how will he like that? Let him know the worst now; if he will not come up to these terms, let him quit his pretensions; as good as the first as at last. " Sell whatsoever thou hast over and above what is necessary for thy support;" probably, he had no family to provide for; let him therefore be a father to the poor, and make them his heirs. Every man, according to his ability, must relieve the poor, and be content, when there is occasion, to straiten himself to do it. Worldly wealth is given us, not only as maintenance to bear our charges through this world, according to our place in it, but as talent, to be used and employed for the glory of our great Master in the world, who hath so ordered it, that the poor we should have always with us as his receivers. (2.) Can he find it in his heart to go through the hardest costliest services he may be called to as a disciple of Christ, and depend upon him for a recompence in heaven? He asks Christ what he should do more than he has done to obtain eternal life, and Christ puts it to him, whether he has indeed that firm belief of, and that high value for, eternal life that he seems to have. Doth he really believe there is a true treasure in heaven sufficient to make up all he can leave, or lose, or lay out, for Christ? Is he willing to deal with Christ upon trust? Can he give him credit for all he is worth; and be willing to bear a present cross, in expectation of a future crown?
2. Upon this he flew off ( v. 22 ); He was sad at that saying; was sorry that he could not be a follower of Christ upon any easier terms than leaving all to follow him; that he could not lay hold on eternal life, and keep hold of his temporal possessions too. But since he could not come up to the terms of discipleship, he was so fair as not to pretend to it; He went away grieved. Here appeared the truth of that ( Matt. vi. 24 ), Ye cannot serve God and mammon; while he held to mammon he did in effect despise Christ, as all those do who prefer the world before him. He bids for what he has a mind for in the market, yet goes away grieved, and leaves it, because he cannot have it at his own price. Two words to a bargain. Motions are not marriages. That which ruined this young man was, he had great possessions; thus the prosperity of fools destroys them, and those who spend their days in wealth are tempted to say to God, Depart from us; or to their hearts, Depart from God.
III. Here is Christ's discourse with his disciples. We are tempted to wish that Christ had mollified that saying which frightened this young gentleman from following him, and by an explanation taken off the harshness of it: but he knew all men's hearts; he would not court him to be his follower, because he was a rich man and a ruler; but, if he will go, let him go. Christ will keep no man against his will; and therefore we do not find that Christ called him back, but took this occasion to instruct his disciples in two things.
1. The difficulty of the salvation of those who have an abundance of this world; because there are few who have a deal to leave, that can be persuaded to leave it for Christ, or to lay it out in doing good.
(1.) Christ asserts this here; He looked about upon his disciples, because he would have them all take notice of what he said, that by it they might have their judgments rightly informed, and their mistakes rectified, concerning worldly wealth, which they were apt to over-rate; How hardly shall they who have riches enter into the kingdom of God! v. 23 . They have many temptations to grapple with, and many difficulties to get over, which lie not in the way of poor people. But he explains himself, v. 24 , where he calls the disciples children, because as such they should be taught by him, and portioned by him with better things than this young man left Christ to cleave to; and whereas he had said, How hardly will those who have riches get to heaven; here he tells them, that the danger arose not so much from their having riches as from their trusting to them, and placing their confidence in them, expecting protection, provision, and a portion from them; saying that to their gold, which they should say only to their God, Thou art my hope, Job xxxi. 24 . They have such a value as this for the wealth of the world, will never be brought to put a right value upon Christ and his grace. They that have ever so much riches, but do not trust in them, that see the vanity of them, and their utter insufficiency to make a soul happy, have got over the difficulty, and can easily part with them for Christ: but they have ever so little, if they set their hearts upon that little, and place their happiness in it, it will keep them from Christ. He enforces this assertion with, v. 25 , It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man, that trusts in riches, or inclines to do so, to enter into the kingdom of God. The disproportion here seems so great (though the more it is so the more it answers the intention), that some have laboured to bring the camel and the eye of the needle a little nearer together. [1.] Some imagine there might be some wicket-gate, or door, to Jerusalem, commonly known by the name of the needle's eye, for its straitness, through which a camel could not be got, unless he were unloaded, and made to kneel, as those camel, Gen. xxiv. 11 . So a rich man cannot get to heaven unless he is willing to part with the burthen of his worldly wealth, and stoop to the duties of a humble religion, and so enter at the strait gate. [2.] Others suggest that the word we translate a camel, sometimes signifies a cable-rope, which, though not to be got through a needle's eye, yet is of great affinity to it. A rich man, compared with the poor, is as a cable to a single thread, stronger, but not so pliable, and it will not go through the needle's eye, unless it be untwisted. So the rich man must be loosed and disentangled from his riches, and then there is some hope of him, that thread by thread he may be got through the eye of the needle, otherwise he is good for nothing but to cast anchor in the earth.
(2.) This truth was very surprising to the disciples; They were astonished at his words, v. 24 . They were astonished out of measure, and said among themselves, Who then can be saved? They knew what were generally the sentiments of the Jewish teachers, who affirmed that the Spirit of God chooses to reside in rich men; nay, they knew what abundance of promises there were, in the Old Testament, of temporal good things; they knew likewise that all either are rich, or fain would be so, and that they who are rich, have so much the larger opportunities of doing good, and therefore were amazed to hear that it should be so hard for rich people to go to heaven.
(3.) Christ reconciled them to it, by referring it to the almighty power of God, to help even rich people over the difficulties that lie in the way of their salvation ( v. 27 ); He looked upon them, to engage their attention, and said, " With men it is impossible; rich people cannot by their own skill or resolution get over these difficulties, but the grace of God can do it, for with him all things are possible. " If the righteous scarcely are saved, much more may we say so of the rich; and therefore when any get to heaven, they must give all the glory to God, who worketh in them both to will and to do.
Sirach uses the vocabulary of the altar for the moral life. Keeping the law multiplieth offerings (v. 1), heeding the commandments is a wholesome sacrifice (v. 2), departing from injustice is a propitiatory sacrifice (v. 3), and he that doth mercy, offereth sacrifice (v. 4), to which the Greek adds "of praise." Calmet finds the Temple's whole system named in these verses: the peace-offering, the sin-offering, the oblation of fine flour and the offering of praise, which he calls the most perfect of all. Then, at verse 10, the passage turns to actual gifts, firstfruits and tithes. Give glory to God with a good heart reads literally "mind" in the Latin and "eye" in the Greek, which Haydock takes as an eye free from avarice, citing 2 Corinthians ix. 7.
The commentators keep both halves in view. Calmet's summary of the opening is "virtue is the most acceptable sacrifice," and Worthington ranks the sacrifices of penance, justice and praise before all external ones, yet Worthington also insists that external sacrifice must not be neglected, and Calmet calls the passage "the true spirit of the law." Verse 6, thou shalt not appear empty in the sight of the Lord, raises the case of the poor. Haydock holds that the poor who bring a virtuous heart are more acceptable than the rich who are buried in sin, however splendid their offerings. Calmet notes that some inferred from Exodus xxiii. 16 that the poor were rejected, and answers that this passage explains what the law meant: God requires each to give according to ability, and from someone who has nothing, keeping the commandments will satisfy Him.
This answers both the man who thinks ritual excuses injustice and the man who thinks a good heart excuses giving nothing. Sirach asks for the firstfruits of thy hands undiminished (v. 10), tithes sanctified with joy (v. 11), a gift measured by what he hath given to thee (v. 12). Calmet glosses sanctify as setting apart for the ministers and the Temple, and Worthington adds that God will reward the giver much more. The image Sirach leaves is the cheerful countenance of verse 11 and the good eye of verse 12, the giver whose eye is free from avarice.