✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 324 · Year II · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year II

Tuesday of the 4th week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · 2 Samuel 18:9-10, 14b, 24-25a, 30–19:3

No verses found for this reference.
commentary

Absalom is left hanging "between the heaven and the earth" (v. 9), and the commentators keep to the physical facts. Calmet says the branches of the oak held him so that he could not escape, and Menochius adds that his beautiful curls were caught as well. Joab's reply to the man who saw it, Not as thou wilt (v. 14), stands in the Hebrew as "I will not tarry thus with thee," which Haydock takes as a refusal to stand arguing or to follow the man's caution; he drives three lances into the heart of a man still alive on the tree. The scene then moves to David at the city. Calmet explains the two gates of v. 24 as one opening on the town and one on the country, with a chamber between them for public meetings and another above, and a watchman posted on the roof. The king reasons from the runner's solitude (v. 25). Calmet says that a routed army would have come back in confusion, and Menochius that a victorious one would be busy plundering, so one man alone means news.

Chusai's answer to the only question David asks, whether the young man Absalom is safe (v. 32), is evasive in form. Menochius calls it as much as saying plainly that he was dead, or at least taken, and Haydock observes that David understood him right. Challoner, citing Ambrose and Theodoret, reads the lament of v. 33 by its motive. David mourned the wretched state in which Absalom died, and would have saved his life by giving his own, and in this he figured Christ weeping, praying and dying for rebellious children, even for those who crucified him. Calmet sets the scene beside an earlier grief. David soon ceased weeping for the child of Bethsabee, because he had reason to hope that child was saved, and the contrast leaves Absalom without that hope.

Menochius notes that the king wept in private, in the chamber over the gate, yet the whole army heard of it, and the victory "was turned into mourning" (v. 2), as he says is usual in civil wars, where a triumph is out of season. The reading lends nothing to Joab's haste, nor to the satisfaction of seeing a rebel get what he earned, nor to a grief that only counts its own loss. Challoner's David weeps for the state in which his son died and wishes the death had been his. That is a harder sorrow, and the text sets it in a gatehouse with the people waiting outside. Calmet renders the people's shunned (v. 3) by the Hebrew "stole away," and Menochius has them entering at last by another gate, a winning army coming home like men who had fled the field.

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.