✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Tue · Nov 16, 2027 · Ordinary Time

Saint Margaret of Scotland/Saint Gertrude the Great, Virgin

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · 2 Maccabees 6:18-31

18Eleazar one of the chief of the scribes, a man advanced in years, and of a comely countenance, was pressed to open his mouth to eat swine's flesh.19But he, choosing rather a most glorious death than a hateful life, went forward voluntarily to the torment.20And considering in what manner he was to come to it, patiently bearing, he determined not to do any unlawful things for the love of life.21But they that stood by, being moved with wicked pity, for the old friendship they had with the man, taking him aside, desired that flesh might be brought which it was lawful for him to eat, that he might make as if he had eaten, as the king had commanded, of the flesh of the sacrifice:22That by so doing he might be delivered from death; and for the sake of their old friendship with the man, they did him this courtesy.23But he began to consider the dignity of his age, and his ancient years, and the inbred honour of his grey head, and his good life and conversation from a child; and he answered without delay, according to the ordinances of the holy law made by God, saying, that he would rather be sent into the other world.24For it doth not become our age, said he, to dissemble: whereby many young persons might think that Eleazar, at the age of fourscore and ten years, was gone over to the life of the heathens:25And so they, through my dissimulation, and for a little time of a corruptible life, should be deceived, and hereby I should bring a stain and a curse upon my old age.26For though, for the present time, I should be delivered from the punishments of men, yet should I not escape the hand of the Almighty neither alive nor dead.27Wherefore, by departing manfully out of this life, I shall shew myself worthy of my old age:28And I shall leave an example of fortitude to young men, if with a ready mind and constancy I suffer an honourable death, for the most venerable and most holy laws. And having spoken thus, he was forthwith carried to execution.29And they that led him, and had been a little before more mild, were changed to wrath for the words he had spoken, which they thought were uttered out of arrogancy.30But when be was now ready to die with the stripes, he groaned: and said: O Lord, who hast the holy knowledge, thou knowest manifestly that whereas I might be delivered from death, I suffer grievous pains in body: but in soul am well content to suffer these things, because I fear thee.31Thus did this man die, leaving not only to young men, but also to the whole nation, the memory of his death, for an example of virtue and fortitude.

commentary

The offer made to Eleazar is a kindness, and the narrator calls it wicked pity (v. 21). Old friends among the officials propose that he bring meat he is allowed to eat and merely appear to eat the sacrificial flesh, so that he might be delivered from death (v. 22). Haydock notes that the Greek behind this has splagchnismo, the sacrificial feast in which the entrails were eaten, and that the Vulgate prefers pity because the men seemed moved by it. The torment Eleazar walks toward voluntarily (v. 19) is in the Greek tumpanizesthai, which Haydock renders "bastinaded" and Calmet thinks St. Paul had in mind in Hebrews 11:35. Eleazar's age is given exactly, fourscore and ten years (v. 24), and his refusal rests on it.

Calmet reports that the Fathers call Eleazar the father of the seven brothers and the protomartyr of the old law, though Haydock points out that unnamed martyrs died before him earlier in the chapter. Ambrose makes him a priest, and Worthington describes him as learned in the Scriptures and in all knowledge, divine and human. Challoner explains why the pity was wicked: it proposed saving his life by dissimulation. Worthington states the principle flatly, that to feign consent to a false religion is never lawful. Calmet sharpens the case. What Eleazar was offered was in itself lawful, since the meat was clean, but it would have been taken as apostasy, and he refused to scandalize the weak. Calmet links this to the teaching of Christ and of Paul in Romans 14 and 1 Corinthians 8 on not causing a weaker brother to fall. Verse 26 widens the horizon. Calmet calls it as plain a statement of punishment after death as could be, a truth unfolding more clearly as the Messias drew near. Worthington adds that the saints of the old law, dying, went not to heaven but to limbo, which is why Eleazar speaks of being sent into the other world.

Most modern compromises look like the one offered here: a private exception, discreetly arranged by well-meaning friends, that costs no one anything visible. Eleazar's refusal judges it on one ground, the young who would see a ninety-year-old man gone over to the life of the heathens (v. 24) and be deceived for a little time of a corruptible life (v. 25). Ambrose, through Worthington, supplies the phrase: Old age ought to be the haven, not the shipwreck, of a former life. Eleazar's last prayer separates body from soul, grievous pains in the one and contentment in the other, because I fear thee (v. 30). The narrator ends with him dead under the stripes, leaving his death as an example to the young men and to the whole nation (v. 31).

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading 2 Maccabees 6:18-31

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
6:18

Scribes; a priest. (St. Ambrose) --- He suffered at Antioch, before the king, chap. vii. 1. (Josephus, [Antiquities?] l. 2.) --- The Fathers highly extol his fortitude and virtue, styling him the father of the seven brothers, and the protomartyr of the old law. (Calmet) --- Yet we find others unnamed suffering before him, ver. 10. (Haydock) --- Eleazar was learned in the Scriptures, and in all divine and human knowledge. (Worthington)

6:19

Hateful. Greek, "criminal life, and went first of his own accord to be bastinaded;" Greek: tumpanizesthai. (Haydock) --- St. Paul probably alluded to this torment, Hebrews xi. 35. It was used among the Jews. (Calmet, Diss.)

6:20

Life. He would not eat swine's flesh to save it. Greek, "But spitting it out, (as those ought to come forward who expect to be tortured; or avenged. Greek: amunesthai) of which things it is not lawful to taste through love of life." (Haydock)

6:21

Wicked pity. Their pity was wicked, in as much as it suggested that wicked proposal of saving his life by dissimulation. (Challoner) --- To feign or make outward shew of consenting to a false religion, is never lawful. (Worthington) --- Greek, "They were set over that wicked feast or sacrifice," Greek: splagchnismo, (Haydock) in which the entrails were eaten. (Calmet) --- In this sense the term is used [in] ver. 7 and 8 by the Vulgate. Here Pity is preferred, as the man seemed to be actuated by it. (Haydock) --- This generous martyr would not scandalize the weak, by doing a thing in itself lawful, which would have been deemed a prevarication. He was guided by those excellent maxims which Christ, St. Paul, and St. Saba (Mart. Ap. xii.) have inculcated and practised, Matthew xviii. 7., and Romans xiv. 14., and 1 Corinthians viii. 4, 10. (Calmet)

6:23

The other. Literally, "hell," or the grave. (Haydock) --- Under the old law the saints could not enter heaven, but at their departure were detained in limbo. (Worthington) --- Some holy doctors have declared that they would rather go to hell than commit a sin. (St. Anselm) --- They understand by hell the torments of that place, but not the opposition to God's will, which is found in the damned, and constitutes one of the greatest of their pains. (Haydock)

6:24

Age. "Old age ought to be the haven, not the shipwreck, of a former life." (St. Ambrose, de Jacob.) (Worthington)

6:26

Dead. Nothing could be more express for the torments after death. As the time of the Messias drew near, these truths were more developed, chap. vii. 9., and Wisdom v. 16., and Psalm i. 6. (Calmet) (Grotius) (Matthew xii. 32.)

6:27

CHAPTER VI.

6:30

Pains. Some of the martyrs seem not to have felt their torments. God made them suffer no more than they could bear. (Haydock)