✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 314 · Year II · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year II

Thursday of the 2nd week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · 1 Samuel 18:6-9; 19:1-7

1 Samuel 18

6Now when David returned, after he slew the Philistine, the women came out of all the cities of Israel, singing and dancing, to meet king Saul, with timbrels of joy, and cornets.7And the women sung as they played, and they said: Saul slew his thousands, and David his ten thousands.8And Saul was exceeding angry, and this word was displeasing in his eyes, and he said: They have given David ten thousands, and to me they have given but a thousand, what can he have more but the kingdom?9And Saul did not look on David with a good eye from that day and forward.

1 Samuel 19

1And Saul spoke to Jonathan, his son, and to all his servants, that they should kill David. But Jonathan, the son of Saul, loved David exceedingly.2And Jonathan told David, saying: Saul, my father, seeketh to kill thee: wherefore look to thyself, I beseech thee, in the morning and thou shalt abide in a secret place, and shalt be hid.3And I will go out and stand beside my father in the field where thou art: and I will speak of thee to my father, and whatsoever I shall see, I will tell thee.4And Jonathan spoke good things of David to Saul, his father: and said to him: Sin not, O king, against thy servant, David, because he hath not sinned against thee, and his works are very good towards thee.5And he put his life in his hand, and slew the Philistine, and the Lord wrought great salvation for all Israel. Thou sawest it and didst rejoice. Why therefore wilt thou sin against innocent blood, by killing David, who is without fault?6And when Saul heard this, he was appeased with the words of Jonathan, and swore: As the Lord liveth, he shall not be slain.7Then Jonathan called David, and told him all these words: and Jonathan brought in David to Saul, and he was before him, as he had been yesterday and the day before.

commentary

The song that ruins Saul was antiphonal. Calmet observes that Scripture preserves only the chorus, and Josephus fills in the performance: the women sang Saul slew his thousands, and the virgins answered and David his ten thousands (v. 7). The dancing of v. 6 is a Hebrew word that also covers playing on the flute or a similar instrument, and the whole scene belongs to a recognised type — Miriam after the Red Sea, Jephte's daughter at the door. Nor were the numbers absurd: Haydock's defence of the couplet is that Goliath's death was worth the slaughter of thousands, since that one man had filled the whole army of Israel with dismay. Even the text of the passage carries a scar from what follows: the Vatican Septuagint drops everything from Saul's outburst to v. 12, though the Alexandrian copy agrees with the Vulgate. What it keeps is v. 9 — Saul did not look on David with a good eye — which the Septuagint renders "Saul suspected," and the Chaldean, more bluntly, "laid snares for David."

Chrysostom puts a share of the blame on the singers: an indiscretion born of excess zeal, since it is always galling for a sovereign to hear a subject preferred to him. Calmet declines to let that settle the matter, asking the question that reframes the whole episode — was David responsible for what was spoken in his praise? Saul's grievance is not really the arithmetic, as his own words admit: what can he have more but the kingdom? Calmet notes the jealousy was sharpened because Saul had already been threatened with the loss of the crown and could see every royal qualification in the young man, and he quotes Pliny's maxim to Trajan for the mechanism — A malo principe tanquam successor timetur quisquis est dignior: under a bad prince, whoever is worthier is feared as a successor. Worthington states the moral flatly, that the proud cannot bear the praises of others. The next scene sets the alternative beside it. Menochius points out that Jonathan had the strongest motive of anyone to want David dead, being the heir whose place he threatened, and that friendship would have been the perfect cover; Haydock adds that Saul must have been a stranger to his son's generosity ever to have made the proposal. Instead Jonathan argues the case on the facts — he put his life in his hand, and slew the Philistine... Thou sawest it and didst rejoice (19:5) — and wins an oath. Whether Saul meant it divides the commentators: Calmet thinks his inconstant temper was momentarily moved and that he presently relapsed, if he was ever sincere at all, while Menochius holds that Scripture seems to insinuate he was.

The passage anatomises a sin that rarely announces itself. Saul does not decide to hate David; he hears a number, and after that he cannot see the man without seeing a rival. The modern version fits the same reflex to smaller stakes: the colleague's promotion that arrives as an accusation, the reputation weighed less for what it is than for what it implies about one's own. Jonathan's answer is worth attending to because it is not a sentiment. He does not tell his father to feel differently; he states what David did, points out that Saul rejoiced at it at the time, and names the act being contemplated for what it is: sin against innocent blood. The chapter ends with the arrangement apparently repaired — David brought back in, standing before the king as he had been yesterday and the day before — and with a suspicion that has already learned how to wait.

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading 1 Samuel 18:6-9; 19:1-7

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
18:6

Philistine. Some explain this of some fresh achievement against that nation, (Malvenda; Worthington) but without reason. --- Dancing. Hebrew also playing on the flute, or on some such instrument of music. (Calmet) --- So Mary [Miriam] sung after the Israelites had crossed the Red Sea, Exodus xv. 20., 2 Kings i. 20., and Judges xi. 34.

18:7

Sung. The chorus of their song is given. (Calmet) --- "The women sung, Saul slew his thousands; and the virgins answered, And David," &c. (Josephus) --- The death of Goliath was equivalent to the slaughter of thousands, as he had filled the whole army of Israel with dismay. (Haydock)

18:8

A thousand. These women were guilty of an indiscretion, through excess of zeal, as it is always displeasing for the sovereign to hear any of his subjects preferred before him. (St. Chrysostom, hom. i. de Saul.) --- The jealousy of Saul was the more excited, as he had been threatened with the loss of his kingdom, and perceived in David all the qualifications of a king. A malo principe tanquam successor timetur quisquis est dignior. (Pliny in Traj.) --- But was David responsible for what was spoken in his praise? (Calmet) --- The Vatican Septuagint omit what follows till ver. 12. "And Saul feared David, (13) and he removed," &c. The Alexandrian copy agrees with the Vulgate. (Haydock) --- Those who are proud, cannot bear the praises of others. (Worthington)

18:9

Eye. Septuagint, "and Saul suspected." (Haydock) --- Chaldean, "laid snares for David." (Calmet)

19:1

Jonathan. He was most interested, as David might be feared as a competitor; (Menochius) and, under the cloak of friendship, he might more easily destroy him. Saul was a stranger to the generous sentiments of his son, or he would never have made the proposal. (Haydock) --- Grotius compares him with Germanicus. (Calmet)

19:2

Morning. Septuagint add, "to-morrow." (Menochius)

19:3

Field. Saul would come thither, or Jonathan would sound his father's disposition, and give David information in the place appointed. (Calmet)

Hand, in danger. (Menochius)

19:6

Slain. His inconstant temper might cause him to be moved with the expostulation of his son; but he presently relapsed, if he were ever sincere. (Calmet) --- The Scripture seems to insinuate that he was. (Menochius)